Article Text
Abstract
Objectives To assess whether the discrepancy between the strong antifibrotic effects of tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) in animal models and the inconsistent results in clinical studies might be related to the activation levels of drug targets.
Methods Skin sections of bleomycin, TSK1, Fra-2 transgenic mice, SSc patients and controls were analysed by histology and immunohistochemistry. Subgroups of mice were treated with the TKIs nilotinib or imatinib. Differences in the activation levels of the TKI targets p-PDGFRβ (platelet derived growth factor β) and p-c-abl were assessed.
Results In bleomycin and TSK1 mice, expression of activated p-PDGFRβ (platelet derived growth factor receptor β) and p-c-abl was ubiquitous with strong upregulation compared with controls. Treatment with TKIs resulted in successful target inhibition and consequently reduced dermal fibrosis. In the Fra-2 model, the activation levels of p-PDGFRβ and p-c-abl were much lower than in the bleomycin and the TSK1 models. Accordingly, nilotinib did not prevent dermal fibrosis and target inhibition was unsuccessful. Notably, in skin biopsies of SSc patients, the mean activation levels of TKI targets were only moderate and in the majority of patients resembled those of the non-responsive Fra-2 model.
Conclusions Animal models for proof-of-concept studies should be selected based on a similar activation level and expression pattern of drug targets as in human SSc.
- Fibroblasts
- Systemic Sclerosis
- Treatment
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Introduction
TGFβ and platelet derived growth factor (PDGF) are pro-fibrotic key molecules in systemic sclerosis (SSc). Because tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) such as imatinib, dasatinib and nilotinib efficiently block TGFβ and PDGF signalling by interfering with c-abl and platelet derived growth factor receptor (PDGFR), they have been evaluated as potential antifibrotic agents in numerous animal models in which they consistently both prevented the onset of fibrosis and improved existing fibrosis in different organs.1–3
This led to clinical trials with TKIs as one of the first molecular targeted therapies in fibrotic diseases. Surprisingly, while open-label uncontrolled studies showed inconsistent results,4 randomised controlled trials failed to find significant antifibrotic effects.5 ,6 The reasons for these striking discrepancies between the convincing and consistent results in animal models and the overall disappointing effects in human fibrotic diseases have not been evaluated. Potential explanations include different activation levels and expression patterns of drug targets in animal models compared with patients.
Therefore, we assessed activation levels and expression patterns of the TKI targets c-abl and PDGFR in different fibrotic animal models and patients with SSc.
Methods
Detailed information on methods is provided in the online supplementary data.
Patients
Skin biopsies were obtained from patients with diffuse (n=10) and limited SSc (n=28) (see online supplementary table S1) fulfilling the LeRoy criteria7 and healthy donors (n=8).
Animals
Skin fibrosis was induced by bleomycin in C57/BL6 mice (n=13).1 Control animals (n=5) were treated with subcutaneous injections of 100 µL 0.9% NaCl. Fra-2 tg mice (n=12)8 ,9 were compared with wt littermates (n=4).
Subgroups of bleomycin challenged (n=9) and Fra-2 tg mice (n=6) were treated with nilotinib at 2×37.5 mg/d twice daily.1 Treatment control groups consisted of mice receiving 100 µL of the vehicle 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidone/PEG300 by oral gavage twice daily (n=4 and 6, respectively).
TSK1 mice (n=8)10 were treated with imatinib at 150 mg/kg/day by intraperitoneal injections and compared with TSK1 (n=10) and pa/pa control mice (n=8) receiving 100 µL of the solvent NaCl intraperitoneally.2
Histology
For the assessment of dermal thickness and extracellular matrix, sections were stained with H&E and Masson's trichrome staining.
Immunohistochemistry
Primary antibodies: mouse monoclonal: anti-α-smooth muscle actin (SMA) (Sigma-Aldrich, Buchs, Switzerland), anti-SM22α (abcam, Cambridge, UK) and anti-prolyl hydroxylase (acris, Nunningen, Switzerland); rabbit polyclonal: anti-von Willebrand factor, anti-p-PDGFRβ and anti-p-c-abl (all from abcam).
Analysis of skin sections
Skin fibrosis was analysed in three consecutive skin sections at ×100 magnification9 by assessing dermal thickness and the number of myofibroblasts (α-SMA+). Differences in the expression of dermal fibroblasts positively stained for TKI targets were determined by manual and automated counting (Image J software) in five randomly chosen high power field (HPF)/section at ×200 magnification.
Statistical analysis
The Kolmogorov–Smirnov test was applied to test for normal distribution. Non-related, non-parametric parameters were analysed with the Mann–Whitney U test, and data are expressed as median(Q1,Q3). Non-related parametric parameters were analysed with the unpaired t test, and data are given as mean±SEM. p Values<0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Results
Response to TKIs in the bleomycin and the TSK1 models is reflected by the expression pattern and high activation status of PDGFRβ and c-abl
In the bleomycin model, a frequently used model of chemically induced dermal fibrosis which reflects early inflammatory stages of SSc, the expression of p-PDGFRβ and p-c-abl was strongly increased. Although the expression of activated PDGFRβ and c-abl was ubiquitous including vascular structures, it was most abundant in fibroblasts scattered throughout the dermis (figure 1A). Accordingly, dermal fibroblasts showed significantly more frequent activation of TKI targets in bleomycin mice compared with controls (figure 1A).
Skin fibrosis was assessed by skin thickness, and confirmed by Masson's trichrome staining and α-SMA+ myofibroblasts counts. In all measures, skin fibrosis was significantly increased in bleomycin mice compared with control mice (figure 1B). Consistent with the high level of activation of TKI targets, nilotinib prevented fibrosis with skin thickness, Masson's trichrome staining and α-SMA+ myofibroblasts counts similar to controls without bleomycin (figure 1B).
In parallel with the prevention of skin fibrosis, the number of p-PDGFR and p-c-abl+ fibroblasts was significantly lower in nilotinib treated than in control bleomycin mice reaching levels as in mice without bleomycin (figure 1A). These data indicate successful target inhibition by nilotinib in the bleomycin model.
In TSK1 mice, a late-stage, non-inflammatory SSc model, the expression of TKI targets in hypodermal fibroblasts was strongly increased (figure 1C) compared with control pa/pa mice. Consistently, imatinib prevented skin fibrosis, which was paralleled by significantly reduced numbers of p-PDGFR and p-c-abl+ fibroblasts in imatinib treated compared with control TSK1 mice (figure 1C).
Lack of antifibrotic effects in Fra-2 tg mice is mirrored by low activation status of the TKI targets PDGFRβ and c-abl
In contrast to the bleomycin model, in Fra-2 tg mice, a genetic model with both fibrosis and vasculopathy, the activation status of TKI targets (figure 2A) was much lower than in the bleomycin model (figure 1A). The number of p-c-abl+ dermal fibroblasts was not different and the number of p-PDGFRβ+ fibroblasts/cells was only slightly increased compared with wt controls.
Using the same measures as in the bleomycin model, Fra-2 tg mice developed significant skin fibrosis compared with wt controls (figure 2B) in agreement with previous reports.9 ,11 However, consistent with the lack of TKI target activation, nilotinib did not prevent skin fibrosis since skin thickness, Masson's trichrome staining and α-SMA+ myofibroblasts counts were not different between nilotinib treated and control animals (figure 2B). Accordingly, Fra-2 tg mice showed similar numbers of p-PDGFR+ and p-c-abl+ fibroblasts in nilotinib treated and control animals indicating lack of target inhibition (figure 2A).
These results suggest that the antifibrotic response could be predicted by the activation status and the expression pattern of the TKI targets in different animal models of SSc.
Activation status and expression pattern of PDGFRβ and c-abl in human SSc
Since in the animal experiments the activation status of TKI targets predicted the treatment response (figures 1 and 2), we next examined the dermal expression of p-PDGFR and p-c-abl in SSc (figure 3).
In patients with limited SSc, the number of p-PDGFR+ dermal fibroblasts did not differ from healthy controls (figure 3A,B), while in diffuse SSc patients, p-PDGFRβ+ dermal fibroblasts were slightly increased compared with healthy controls (figure 3A,B). The number of p-c-abl+ dermal fibroblasts did not differ from controls in all patients with SSc while they were slightly higher in diffuse than in limited SSc patients (figure 3A,B). Notably, while there was heterogeneity in SSc patients with some having levels as in the bleomycin model, the large majority of patients had low activation levels of both TKI targets with mean levels reflecting those seen in Fra-2 tg mice.
The difference of human samples from the TKI-responsive bleomycin and TSK1 models was also reflected in the expression pattern of TKI targets. In SSc patients, the expression of activated PDGFRβ and c-abl was pronounced in vascular structures (figure 3C). Double staining for the respective cell markers revealed that in the skin of SSc patients, p-PDGFRβ and p-c-abl were expressed by vascular smooth muscle cells, endothelial cells and to a lesser extent in dermal fibroblasts. The immunostaining for p-PDGFRβ and p-c-abl in the sections was specific since substitution of the primary antibodies with the respective IgG resulted in absence of the respective staining.
Discussion
Our study showed that the level of target activation and the expression pattern predicted the antifibrotic response to TKIs in three different animal models of SSc. Similarly, upregulation of p-PDGFR in the lung (not skin) of Fra-2 tg mice was recently shown to be accompanied by a significant reduction of pulmonary fibrosis upon treatment with nilotinib.12 In SSc patients, the activation status of TKI targets was only moderate, which might explain the overall disappointing results of clinical trials with TKIs in SSc.
Our findings have important implications for drug development in SSc: (1) The selection of animal models for preclinical proof-of-concept studies should be based—among other parameters13—on the activation level and expression pattern of drug targets. In this context, similar levels of target activation in humans and animal models are crucial to delineate potential treatment responses in human SSc. (2) Our data underline the potential importance of personalised medicine in targeted therapies of SSc. Activation levels of TKI targets were highly heterogeneous in SSc patients. While most patients showed low activation levels, in some the activation status of TKI targets was as high as in the strongly responsive bleomycin model. These data together with recent gene array studies14 ,15 suggest that the analysis of target activation levels could identify patients more likely to benefit from TKI treatment for fibrosis. (3) Our data also suggest that TKI targets might play a role in the vascular manifestations of SSc due to their pronounced expression pattern in vascular structures of SSc patients. Recently, p-PDGFRβ has been suggested as an important molecule in the pathogenesis of pulmonary arterial hypertension,16 and nilotinib prevented the development of proliferative vasculopathy in Fra-2 tg mice.12 In addition, imatinib improved exercise capacity and haemodynamics in patients with advanced pulmonal arterial hypertension (PAH) in a recent randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial.17
Acknowledgments
The authors thank Maria Comazzi for the excellent technical support.
References
Supplementary materials
Supplementary Data
This web only file has been produced by the BMJ Publishing Group from an electronic file supplied by the author(s) and has not been edited for content.
Files in this Data Supplement:
- Data supplement 1 - Online supplement
Footnotes
-
Handling editor Tore K Kvien
-
Contributors BM, OD: Conception and design of the study, analysis and interpretation of data, drafting the article. AD, CD: Participation in animal experiments. AD, CD, KK, CPD, DA, REG, SG, BAM: Analysis and interpretation of data, critical revision of the manuscript. JHWD: Conception and design of the study, analysis and interpretation of data, critical revision of the manuscript. All authors have given their final approval of the manuscript to be published as presented. BM and OD accept full responsibility for the work and/or the conduct of the study, had access to the data, and controlled the decision to publish.
-
Competing interests JHWD has consultancy relationships and/or has received research funding from Boehringer Ingelheim, Celgene, Bayer Pharma, Actelion, Pfizer, Ergonex, BMS, JB Therapeutics, Anaphore, Inc, Sanofi-Aventis, Novartis, Array Biopharma and Active Biotec in the area of potential treatments of scleroderma and is stock owner of 4D Science. OD has/had consultancy relationship and/or has received research funding in the area of systemic sclerosis and related conditions from Actelion, Pfizer, Ergonex, BMS, Sanofi-Aventis, United BioSource Corporation, Roche/Genentech, medac, Biovitrium, Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma, Novartis, 4D Science, Active Biotec, Bayer-Schering Sinoxa, Serodapharm and EpiPharm. CPD has been a consultant to, or received honoraria from, Actelion, Pfizer, Ergonex, Sanofi-Aventis, United BioSource Corporation, Roche/Genentech, Biovitrium, Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma, Novartis and Digna pharmaceuticals. All authors were supported by their respective institutions. The real or perceived potential conflicts listed above are accurately stated.
-
Patient consent Obtained and is stated in the online data supplement.
-
Ethics approval Obtained and is stated in the online data supplement.
-
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.