Table 4 Denuded surface areas (mm2) trimmed: baseline value, annualised mean (SD) change, annualised percentage (SD) change (n = 150)
LocationBaseline mean (SD)No. (%) of participants with denuded area at baselineMean change (SD) from modelSRMMean change in knees with K&L = 2 or 3(SD) n = 116Mean change in knees with K&L = 2–4 and varus angulation (SD) n = 59
Femur176.64 (241.21)124 (82.7)8.97 (37.26)0.24117.58 (48.80)8.38 (58.75)
Lat Tibia6.91 (28.06)55 (36.7)0.96 (9.22)0.1040.63 (11.73)−0.48 (6.21)
Med Tibia44.16 (109.13)69 (46.0)2.06 (21.62)0.0952.38 (17.72)3.44 (21.34)
Patella97.71 (208.50)81 (54.0)−1.64 (30.47)−0.054−0.60 (35.10)−3.54 (28.18)
Trochlea99.07 (198.43)89 (59.3)1.14 (23.48)0.0499.88 (41.67)−0.25 (46.49)
Cent Lat Femur4.03 (18.15)84 (56.0)0.65 (5.48)0.1180.77 (6.12)0.63 (2.55)
Cent Lat Tibia4.57 (24.51)89 (59.3)0.76 (8.93)0.0850.78 (10.68)−0.86 (4.97)
Cent Med Femur60.88 (128.69)93 (62.0)6.47 (27.08)0.2396.64 (22.24)8.35 (33.63)
Cent Med Tibia43.28 (107.76)90 (60.0)1.79 (19.36)0.0922.17 (16.93)3.13 (20.80)
Post Lat Femur1.00 (6.19)7 (4.7)0.37 (2.82)0.1310.41 (2.76)0.037 (0.12)
Post Med Femur8.76 (35.49)84 (56.0)0.16 (10.69)0.0150.15 (9.91)−0.15 (13.85)
Cent+Post Med Femur69.64 (147.74)94 (62.7)6.63 (30.88)0.2156.79 (26.87)8.20 (38.07)
Cent+PostMedFemur+MedTibia113.81 (248.61)109 (72.7)8.69 (42.65)0.2049.17 (37.50)11.64 (49.58)
  • Cent, central; K&L, Kellgren and Lawrence (grade); Lat, lateral; Med, medial; Post, posterior; SRM, standardised response mean.

  • Percentage of change on denuded surface areas was not defined because some knees had zero baseline values and non-zero follow-up values.