Article Text
Abstract
Background Antinuclear antibody (ANA) detection by indirect immunofluorescence technique (ANA-IIF) is the standard test for connective tissue disease (CTD) screening for last 5 decades, which has low specificity and it is labour intensive. ANA detection by fluoroenzyme immunoassay (ANA-Elia) has been developed recently as an alternative method to include 17 ANA-targeted recombinant antigens.
Objectives Compare the sensitivity and specificity of the new ANA-Elia with conventional ANA-IIF.
Methods Randomly selected 1458 patient’s sera from primary and secondary health care were tested for both the standard ANA-IIF (Diasorin S.P.A, saluggia, Italy) and the new ANA-Elia (Phadia GMbH, Ferieiburg, Germany). ANA-Elia is fluoroenzyme immunoassay performed on the Phadia-250 automated platform. It contains 17 ANA-targeted recombinant antigens; dsDNA, Sm-D, Rib-P, PCNA, U1-RNP (70, A, C), SS-A/Ro (52 and 60), SS-B/La, Centromere B, Scl-70, Fibrillarin, RNA Polymerase III, Jo-1, Mi-2, and PMscl. Result with ratio >1.0 considered positive for the new technique. For ANA-IIF our lab cut off for positive test is ≥1:80. Patients were evaluated in our rheumatology clinic for fulfilling the correspondent international clinical criteria for various connective tissue diseases.
Results 75.7% were females with mean age of 43±13 years. 201 (11.5%) patients confirmed to have clinical CTD as follow: 142 SLE, 24 Sjogren’s syndrome, 15 scleroderma, 7 MCT, 10 Myositis and 10 undifferentiated CTD. The specificity of ANA-Elia at cut off ratio of >1 and ANA-IIF at titer of ≥1:80 was almost equal, 88.5% and 87.6% respectively. However, ANA-Elia has higher sensitivity (74.5%) as compared to ANA-IIF (61.6%). At a higher cut off ratio of >2 and titer of ≥1:160, the specificity improved to 93.6%–92.6% respectively.
Conclusions The ANA testing with the newly developed, use friendly, fully automated and less labour intense method of ANA-Elia can replace the standard conventional ANA-IIF with better specificity.
Disclosure of Interest None declared