Background In systemic sclerosis (SSc), chronic and uncontrolled overexpression of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) results in chaotic vessels, and intractable fingertip ulcers. Vice versa, VEGF is a potent mediator of angiogenesis if temporally and spatially controlled. We have addressed this therapeutic dilemma in SSc by a novel approach using a VEGF121 variant that covalently binds to fibrin and gets released on demand by cellular enzymatic activity. Using University of California at Davis (UCD)-206 chickens, we tested the hypothesis that cell-demanded release of fibrin-bound VEGF121 leads to the formation of stable blood vessels, and clinical improvement of ischaemic lesions.
Methods Ninety-one early and late ischaemic comb and neck skin lesions of UCD-206 chickens were treated locally with VEGF121-fibrin, fibrin alone, or left untreated. After 1 week of treatment the clinical outcome was assessed. Angiogenesis was studied by immunofluorescence staining of vascular markers quantitatively analysed using TissueQuest.
Results Overall, 79.3% of the lesions treated with VEGF121-fibrin showed clinical improvement, whereas 71.0% of fibrin treated controls, and 93.1% of untreated lesions deteriorated. This was accompanied by significantly increased growth of stable microvessels, upregulation of the proangiogenic VEGFR-2 and its regulator TAL-1, and increase of endogenous endothelial VEGF expression.
Conclusions Our findings in the avian model of SSc suggest that cell-demanded release of VEGF121 from fibrin matrix induces controlled angiogenesis by differential regulation of VEGFR-1 and VEGFR-2 expression, shifting the balance towards the proangiogenic VEGFR-2. The study shows the potential of covalently conjugated VEGF-fibrin matrices for the therapy of ischaemic lesions such as fingertip ulcers.
- Systemic Sclerosis
- Outcomes research
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt and build upon this work, for commercial use, provided the original work is properly cited. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Systemic sclerosis (SSc, scleroderma), a devastating autoimmune connective tissue disease affecting the skin and viscera, is characterised by microangiopathy, immunological abnormalities and fibrosis.1 Although great progress has been made in unscrambling the complex pathogenic interactions between the immune system, the vasculature and fibrotic processes, the ultimate aetiology still remains unclear.2 However, apoptosis of endothelial cells (ECs) is considered to be a primary event in the pathogenesis of SSc that precedes inflammation and fibrosis.3
The search for the ultimate aetiology as well as the evaluation of new therapeutic approaches requires appropriate animal models. The University of California at Davis (UCD) chicken lines 200 and 206 are the only animal model displaying all hallmarks of SSc, that is, microvascular damage, severe perivascular mononuclear cell infiltration, and fibrosis of skin and viscera, circulating antinuclear antibodies, and anti-EC antibodies.4
Vascular alterations in human and avian SSc predominantly affect the microvasculature with intimal proliferation, occlusion of blood vessel and capillary necrosis, leading to a decreased blood flow, a state of chronic ischaemia and clinical manifestations such as fingertip ulcers and comb lesions.5 ,6 Tissue hypoxia normally induces neoangiogenesis, but in SSc vascular repair and angiogenesis seem to be strongly disturbed.7–9 One of the key molecules in the induction of angiogenesis is vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). It is involved in several steps of angiogenesis including migration, proliferation and survival of ECs.10 In patients with SSc, VEGF expression is upregulated, but seems to be uncontrolled and chronic.11–14 Sufficient angiogenesis depends on the tight regulation of VEGF expression.15 Prolonged exposure to VEGF results in the formation of a chaotic capillary network with irregularly shaped, dilated capillaries, a morphology similar to that seen in SSc.16 ,17 Thus, the chronic VEGF overexpression found in SSc might paradoxically lead to a disturbed vessel morphology rather than to promote the formation of new functional and stable vessels. Recently, increased serum levels of the antiangiogenic VEGF165b isoform have been reported in patients with SSc, which could at least partly explain the lack of sufficient angiogenesis despite strongly elevated VEGF levels.18 However, very high levels of VEGF are associated with the absence of fingertip ulcers.11 ,19 This suggests that the concentrations of proangiogenic VEGF isoforms have to exceed a certain threshold level to overcome the inhibitory effects of antiangiogenic factors, and that a further increase of VEGF might have beneficial effects in the prevention and therapy of fingertip ulcers. Yet, therapeutic VEGF can play either a helpful or harmful role in tissue vascularisation, depending on the dose and pharmacokinetics of its administration.16 ,20 ,21 Hence, uncontrolled long-term overexpression as in SSc or a burst release leads to chaotic morphology of the newly formed vessels with reduced blood flow, whereas a short-time upregulation of VEGF initiates angiogenesis, which results in the formation of stable blood vessels.22 Thus, in SSc, there is a therapeutic need for a temporally and spatially controlled availability of proangiogenic VEGF at sites of ischaemia (eg, fingertip ulcers).
In nature, the longer VEGF isoforms are bound to extracellular matrix (ECM) components until liberated in a tightly controlled manner by local enzymatic activity of cells invading the matrix.23 The ECM provides a bioactive dynamic structure, which controls EC activities by various mechanisms ranging from cell anchorage and growth factor binding to integrin-mediated activation, and thus is crucial for functional and sustained vascular growth.24 In order to mimic nature, Andreas Zisch et al25 have developed a method to covalently bind VEGF121 to a fibrin matrix, in which VEGF121 is released upon demand by enzymatic cleavage. Grafting experiments with this fibrin-bound VEGF variant demonstrated controlled growth of morphologically normal blood vessels.26 Based on this evidence, we hypothesised that local administration of VEGF121-fibrin and consequent cell demanded release of VEGF from the fibrin matrix should overcome the uncontrolled VEGF expression found in SSc, and induce sufficient angiogenesis to heal and prevent ischaemic ulcers. Here we present the therapeutic efficacy of this novel approach in the spontaneous avian model of SSc.
Materials and methods
Animals and study design
UCD-206 chickens were bred and maintained at the Central Laboratory Animal Facilities of the Medical University of Innsbruck. Animal breeding, housing, treatment and collection of tissue samples were carried out in accordance with the Animal Experiment Directive of the European Union (Directive 2010/63 EU) and the Austrian law on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes (‘Tierversuchsgesetz’ BGBL I Nr. 501/1989 idF 2005 and BGBL I Nr. 114/2012) after approval by the Federal Ministry of Science and Research (GZ 66.011/082-C/GT/2007, GZ 66.011/082-C/GT/2010, and GZ 66.011/077-WF/II/3b/2014). The clinical stage of early skin lesions is classified in the comb as C+ (erythema), C++ (erythema and oedema), C+++ (ulceration with onset of necrosis), C++++ (comb lost due to self dubbing) in the neck skin as N+ (erythema), N++ (erythema and oedema), and N+++ (ulceration with onset of necrosis), N++++ (fibrosis).3 Comb lesions developed between 9 days and 27 days of age (mean 14.7±4.1 SD), neck lesions between 22 days and 37 days of age (mean 26.0±3.9 SD).
For the present study, lesions were treated at the stages of C++ and C+++, neck lesions at stage N+++ either with VEGF121 modified fibrin gel, with fibrin gel only, or left untreated (comb lesions n=10 per group, neck lesions treated with VEGF121-fibrin or fibrin n=11 each, untreated n=9). Chickens were randomly assigned to receive VEGF121-fibrin, fibrin or no treatment, and received a code for blinded clinical and histological analyses.
In order to mimic the natural binding of VEGF to ECM, we used VEGF121 modified with the factor XIIIa substrate sequence NQEQVSPL. This variant, α2PI1-8-VEGF121, spontaneously cross-links to fibrinogen by the transglutamination activity of factor XIII (FXIII) during fibrin polymerisation.25 VEGF121-fibrin gel matrices were prepared by mixing 20 μg/mL α2PI1-8-VEGF121 (kindly provided by A Zisch) with fibrinogen solution (Tisseel, Baxter AG, Vienna, Austria) diluted with sterile Tris buffered saline (pH 7.2) to a final concentration of 10 mg/mL fibrinogen, and 2 U/mL FXIII (Baxter AG, Vienna, Austria) prior to initiation of fibrin gelation by addition of 2 U/mL thrombin (Tisseel, Baxter AG, Vienna, Austria). For placebo control, α2PI1-8-VEGF121 was omitted. The mixture was immediately applied to the lesion with the help of a small plastic ring to keep it in place till gel was formed, which took 20–30 s. The ring was then removed, and the gel covered with Opsite Flexigrid (Smith & Nephew, Hull, UK) to keep it moist.
After 7 days, the dressing was removed; pictures were taken for documentation and macroscopic analysis by comparison with pictures taken before treatment. The animals were sacrificed under Narkodorm anaesthesia (Pentobarbital, CP-Pharma, D-31303 Burgdorf, Germany, 20 mg/kg intravenous) by cardiac exsanguinisation. Combs and neck skin biopsies were shock frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at −196°C till further analyses. The clinical outcome was evaluated by three experts (HD, JG and RS) independently, and in a blinded manner. The degree of change was scored as follows: 0=no change, +1=improvement, +2=strong improvement, −1=deterioration, −2=strong deterioration.
Angiogenesis was studied by indirect immunofluorescence (IIF) tests on 4 μm frozen tissue sections using antibodies specific for the EC marker von Willebrand factor (vWF), and α smooth muscle actin (αSMA) or desmin, which are expressed by pericytes (PCs) and smooth muscle cells (SMCs), and serve as markers for stable blood vessel formation. Expression of VEGF, VEGFR-1, VEGFR-2 and TAL-1 by ECs was also analysed by IIF double staining with the respective antibody and anti-vWF antibody. Nuclei were stained with DAPI. See online supplementary text for details on antibodies and staining procedure.
Microscopy and quantitative analysis
IIF staining was analysed in a blinded manner using a Nikon Eclipse E800 fluorescence microscope (Nikon, Tokyo, Japan). For quantitative analysis digital black and white (b/w) pictures were acquired from 10 fields of view per tissue section using a 20× objective lens (Plan Apo 20×/0.75 DICM α/0.17 WD 1.0) with filter settings for FITC, RRX and DAPI in series (jpeg fine, size 1280×960, source s1.3M, CCD mode).
ECs and non-ECs expressing VEGF, VEGFRs or TAL-1 were quantified using the image analysis software TissueQuest cytometer (TQ 4.0 TissueQuest Software, TissueGnostics, Vienna, Austria). This microscopy-based multicolour tissue cytometry software permits multicolour analysis of single cells within tissue sections similar to flow cytometry. The principle of the method and the algorithms used have been described in detail elsewhere.27 In brief, the DAPI channel is the master marker for the identification of all events. This mask is then used in a corrected form to measure staining intensity in the other channels. Cut-off values for FITC and RRX channels were defined according to isotype controls, coexpressions were depicted in scattergrams of normalised grey values, and numbers of single positive and double positive cells were calculated as cells per mm2. To discriminate PCs and SMCs, parameters were chosen in order to identify αSMA positive cells within the basal lamina and outside.
GraphPad Prism software V.6.0 was used for statistical analyses. Since the majority of our data did not pass the D'Agostino and Pearson omnibus normality test, two groups were compared by the non-parametrical Mann-Whitney U test after testing the global null hypothesis by the Kruskal-Wallis test. Local p values were adjusted by the global p value to preserve the family-wise error rate.28 p Values ≤0.05 were considered statistically significant.
To evaluate whether VEGF121 modified fibrin heals and prevents ischaemic ulcerations, we locally treated early inflammatory comb lesions (C++), and late comb and neck skin ulcers (C+++, N+++) of UCD-206 chickens. After 1 week of treatment the clinical outcome was assessed (figure 1). Two animals treated with VEGF121-fibrin had lost the dressing and therefore were excluded from the study, that is, one with C++ lesion and one with N+++ lesion. From the comb lesions treated with VEGF121-fibrin in the early inflammatory C++ stage, six (66.7%) showed improvement, one (11.1%) deterioration and two (22.2%) halt of disease progression. Fibrin treated C++ lesions improved in two chickens (20.0%), worsened in seven (70.0%) and showed no change in one animal. All 10 untreated C++ lesions deteriorated. Nine comb lesions (90.0%) treated with VEGF121-fibrin in the late ischaemic C+++ stage showed improvement, one lesion deteriorated. In the fibrin treated group only one C+++ lesion improved slightly, eight (80.0%) worsened and one (10.0%) was unchanged. In the untreated C+++ group there was one (10.0%) spontaneous healing, one without change and eight (80.0%) with clear deterioration. Ulcerations of neck skin were clearly improved in eight animals (80.0%) after VEGF121-fibrin treatment, and showed no change in two chickens. Fibrin treatment improved only two N+++ lesions (18.2%), two (18.2%) were unaltered and seven (63.6%) progressed further. All 10 untreated lesions were strongly deteriorated. There was 100% agreement between the three blinded independent investigators in the semiquantitative clinical assessment in 60% of the cases; in 38% of the cases, two of the investigators showed 100% concordance, one differed by one degree up or down. The three investigators disagreed only in two cases on the severity of deterioration.
Effect of VEGF121-fibrin on angiogenesis
To assess whether VEGF121-fibrin induces the growth of mature blood vessels, we quantitatively analysed frozen tissue sections stained by IIF with EC specific anti-vWF antibodies and anti-αSMA antibodies as a marker for mural cells. One of the fibrin treated C++ samples was lost due to accidental defrosting, and thus not included in the studies on angiogenesis. Microvascular density was significantly increased in VEGF121-fibrin treated early comb lesions, late comb lesions, and neck skin ulcers compared with fibrin treated and untreated lesions (figure 2A, D, G). The difference was also significant between VEGF121-fibrin and fibrin treated samples. Fibrin itself also increased the number of ECs significantly compared with untreated lesions. PC numbers were significantly elevated in all VEGF121-fibrin treated groups compared with untreated controls (figure 2B, E, H). Fibrin alone increased the number of PCs as well, but to a lesser extent. In late comb and neck ulcers, however, the effect of VEGF121-fibrin was significantly higher than of fibrin only. Significantly more vascular SMCs (vSMCs) were found in all VEGF121-fibrin treated lesions, and fibrin only groups compared with untreated controls (figure 2C, F, I). Increase of mural cell numbers after treatment with VEGF121-fibrin was confirmed by desmin staining (see online supplementary figure S1).
To study the regulatory effects of VEGF121-fibrin on the expression of VEGF receptors VEGFR-1 and VEGFR-2, we determined the numbers of VEGFR-1/vWF double stained cells and the numbers of VEGFR-2/vWF double stained cells using TissueQuest, and calculated first the ratio of VEGFR-1 to VEGFR-2 expressing ECs. We then calculated the change of this ratio (x) in relation to healthy controls with the equation where y is the VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 ratio of individual samples. Whereas in the majority of untreated lesions the VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 ratio was increased in relation to healthy controls, the change of the VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 ratio was significantly lower after VEGF121-fibrin treatment compared with untreated combs, and fibrin treated comb lesions (figure 3A, B). Neck skin lesions also showed a clear change of VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 ratio after treatment with VEGF121-fibrin compared with fibrin and untreated controls. However the significance between groups was lost after Kruskal-Wallis adjustment (VEGF121-fibrin: median=−75.2 (IQR=−90.9 to −53.0), fibrin: −66.5 (−83.1 to 179.1); figure 3C–F). The reduction of the VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 ratio was in part due to increased VEGFR-2 expression. To confirm this finding we also analysed the expression of TAL-1/SCL, a positive regulator of VEGFR-2 (figure 4). Compared with untreated controls VEGF121-fibrin increased the number of TAL-1 expressing ECs in early comb lesions, late comb lesions and neck ulcers. In the latter, the difference between VEGF121-fibrin and fibrin treatment was also statistically significant, whereas in comb lesions TAL-1 expressing ECs were elevated by fibrin compared with untreated controls.
Furthermore, we wanted to know if the exogenous VEGF121-fibrin has an influence on VEGF production by ECs. The number of VEGF expressing ECs was increased after VEGF121-fibrin treatment of comb and neck ulcers compared with fibrin and untreated controls. These differences were clearly significant in C+++, but not significant after Kruskal-Wallis adjustment in neck lesions (VEGF121-fibrin: 235.4 (72.9–636.7), fibrin: 74.1 (36.0–316.8), untreated control: 116.4 (54.9–146.7); figure 5).
The novelty and attractiveness of the current approach lies in the bioavailability of VEGF on cellular demand. This specifically addresses an unmet need in SSc where we have the situation of insufficiently increased VEGF levels. Moreover, some of the overexpressed VEGF might be antiangiogenic.29 Both aspects are addressed by the fibrin-bound VEGF gel: it provides locally in the wound bed sufficient amounts of VEGF and at the same time, the release of VEGF is on demand of the cells and the local release is stopped after it is no longer required. Our study in UCD-206 chickens convincingly showed the clinical efficacy of the topical VEGF121-fibrin therapy. In most cases of early treatment, that is, in combs with oedema but no ulceration, VEGF121-fibrin prevented the development of ischaemic ulcers. In total, only two animals (6.9%) did not respond to VEGF121-fibrin at all, and showed the same disease progression as untreated animals. Spontaneous healing was observed in only one untreated chicken with comb ulcer. Fibrin gel alone had a moderate improving effect on five lesions (16.1%). Overall, 79.3% of the VEGF121-fibrin treated lesions showed clear clinical improvement, whereas 71.0% of fibrin treated controls and 93.1% of untreated lesions had deteriorated. It should be noted here that, although closed bred, UCD-206 chickens are not an inbred line, and thus, like humans do not react uniformly.
VEGF121-fibrin had effectively promoted angiogenesis, leading to increased microvascular density. This is also reflected by significantly more ECs in comb and neck lesions treated with VEGF121-fibrin compared with fibrin or untreated controls. Nascent blood vessels initially consist only of ECs and have to be stabilised by mural cells.30 Mural cells of capillaries are referred to as PCs, those of arteries, arterioles, and veins as vSMCs. They both express αSMA, but can be distinguished by their localisation.31 We have set the parameters of the image analysis software TissueQuest in order to discriminate vSMCs, which are separated from ECs by the basement membrane or in larger arteries by the intima, and PCs, which share the basement membrane with the ECs and are in direct contact with these. Whereas only few mural cells were detected in untreated lesions, all the blood vessels of VEGF121-fibrin treated ulcers looked ensheathed by PCs or vSMCs suggesting the formation of mature, stable vessels. Desmin staining corroborated these findings.
The fibrin glue Tisseel, which we used to form the fibrin matrix, stimulated angiogenesis itself. Fibrin is the major component of blood clots, and serves as a provisional matrix during wound healing. Fibrin supports every stage of angiogenesis, that is, migration of ECs, tube formation and vessel maturation. In a rabbit model of hind limb ischaemia it has been found to promote angiogenesis even without the addition of any other proangiogenic factor.32 Thrombin, another component of Tisseel, as well as FXIII are also known to mediate angiogenesis.33 ,34 FXIII was used to covalently bind VEGF121 to fibrin, but was also added to the placebo control. In vitro and in vivo studies have revealed that FXIII promotes migration and proliferation of ECs, inhibits apoptosis, and downregulates the antiangiogenic factor TSP-1 via VEGFR-2 activation.34 ,35 Thus, all three components might contribute to the therapeutic effect of VEGF121-fibrin. However, VEGF121-fibrin showed significantly greater efficacy than the fibrin sealant with FXIII, especially in the treatment of late ischaemic ulcers of comb and neck skin.
Therapy with VEGF121-fibrin affected the expression of VEGFR-1 and VEGFR-2. Most of the VEGF signalling described to date is primarily mediated via VEGFR-2, that is, survival, migration, proliferation and vascular tube formation.36 In developmental angiogenesis VEGFR-1 acts as decoy receptor negatively regulating VEGFR-2 signalling.37 The role of VEGFR-1 in postnatal angiogenesis is less clear, and seems to be context dependent. However, several lines of evidence suggest an association of increased VEGFR-1 expression with impaired angiogenesis. VEGFR-1 levels are increased in chronic non-healing wounds, whereas in normal healing wounds granulation tissue formation is positively correlated with a decline in VEGFR-1.38 Elevated VEGFR-1 levels have been reported to promote endothelial injury in children with lupus nephritis,39 and to inhibit endothelial repair in PR3-ANCA associated vasculitis.40 Upregulation of VEGFR-1 and VEGFR-2 was demonstrated in SSc skin.14 ,41 However, some of these semiquantitative results are contradictory. Whereas one study described a more pronounced VEGFR-2 expression, the other found more VEGFR-1. In bone marrow, diminished angiogenesis was associated with decreased VEGFR-2 expression and high VEGF levels.42 It is possible that differences between patients and the small sample numbers account for diverging results, but in general, they indicate activation of the VEGF/VEGFR system and imbalanced expression of VEGF and its receptors. VEGF action is regulated by the availability of its receptors. Therefore, it seems very likely that the ratio of VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 rather than the absolute numbers determines the angiogenic status in the tissue. In lesional UCD-206 comb and neck skin the balance between the two receptors is shifted towards VEGFR-1. On exposure to VEGF121-fibrin the VEGFR-1:VEGFR-2 ratio was normalised due to differential regulation of VEGFR-1 and VEGFR-2 expression with a relative increase in endothelial VEGFR-2. Upregulation of VEGFR-2 expression concurred with increased TAL-1 expression. TAL-1 is a basic-helix-loop-helix transcription factor known to be essential for haematopoietic development. It is also required during vascular development and angiogenesis, and has been identified as a positive regulator of VEGFR-2.43 Moreover, endogenous VEGF expression was induced by modified VEGF121 in comb and neck skin ulcers. As autocrine VEGF signalling is required for endothelial survival,44 this might indicate the induction of lasting vascularisation.
All these results support the notion that cell-demanded release of fibrin-bound VEGF is capable of translating a supraphysiological dose into a physiological tiny dose, of sustaining this dose long enough to permit vessels to mature into stable vessels, and of stopping it if no longer needed. Otherwise chronic exposure would have harmful effects again. Furthermore, this study indicates that even a singular local administration of VEGF121-fibrin can achieve sufficient revascularisation to improve existing ulcers or prevent the development of ulcers in our SSc animal model. For clinical applications, long-term effects and potential side effects of VEGF121 need particular attention.
The authors dedicate this paper to the late Andreas Zisch, whose work on biopolymeric matrices for the delivery of growth factors paved the way for successful therapeutic angiogenesis. He was involved in the design of the present study, and we would like to thank him for many fruitful discussions, and for providing α2PI1-8-VEGF121. The authors also thank Gabriele Stöckl for technical assistance.
Review history and Supplementary material
Handling editor Tore K Kvien
Contributors RS and OD conceived and designed the study. RS and HD treated the animals and collected the tissues. JG conceived the grading for the clinical assessment. RS, HD and JG evaluated the clinical outcome. SAB, MM and IW did experiments and analysed the data. RS oversaw all experiments, data analyses and interpretation. RS and SAB wrote the manuscript. OD, HD and JG edited the report. All authors have seen and approved the final manuscript.
Funding This work was funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF): P23230-B13.
Competing interests OD has/had consultancy relationship and/or has received research funding in the area of systemic sclerosis and related conditions from Actelion, Pfizer, Ergonex, BMS, Sanofi-Aventis, United BioSource Corporation, Roche/Genentech, Medac, Biovitrium, Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma, Novartis, 4D Science, Active Biotec, Bayer-Schering, Sinoxa, Serodapharm, EpiPharm, GSK and Biogen.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement Raw data can be provided upon request.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.