Objectives Osteoarthritis (OA) is a leading cause of disability for which there is no cure. The identification of molecules supporting cartilage homeostasis and regeneration is therefore a major pursuit in musculoskeletal medicine. Agrin is a heparan sulfate proteoglycan which, through binding to low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 4 (LRP4), is required for neuromuscular synapse formation. In other tissues, it connects the cytoskeleton to the basement membrane through binding to α-dystroglycan. Prompted by an unexpected expression pattern, we investigated the role and receptor usage of agrin in cartilage.
Methods Agrin expression pattern was investigated in human osteoarthritic cartilage and following destabilisation of the medial meniscus in mice. Extracellular matrix (ECM) formation and chondrocyte differentiation was studied in gain and loss of function experiments in vitro in three-dimensional cultures and gain of function in vivo, using an ectopic cartilage formation assay in nude mice. Receptor usage was investigated by disrupting LRP4 and α-dystroglycan by siRNA and blocking antibodies respectively.
Results Agrin was detected in normal cartilage but was progressively lost in OA. In vitro, agrin knockdown resulted in reduced glycosaminoglycan content, downregulation of the cartilage transcription factor SOX9 and other cartilage-specific ECM molecules. Conversely, exogenous agrin supported cartilage differentiation in vitro and ectopic cartilage formation in vivo. In the context of cartilage differentiation, agrin used an unusual receptor repertoire requiring both LRP4 and α-dystroglycan.
Conclusions We have discovered that agrin strongly promotes chondrocyte differentiation and cartilage formation in vivo. Our results identify agrin as a novel potent anabolic growth factor with strong therapeutic potential in cartilage regeneration.
- Knee Osteoarthritis
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Agrin (AGRN) is a heparan sulfate proteoglycan known for its requirement in neuromuscular synapse formation.1 Recent microarray data from our laboratory identified agrin as a gene expressed in cartilage and modulated upon injury,2 raising the possibility of a novel function for agrin in an aneural tissue such as cartilage, containing only one cell type: the articular chondrocyte.
At the neuromuscular junction, neuronal agrin (splice variant: y4, z8) binds low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 4 (LRP4) in a complex with the muscle-specific kinase (MuSK) and amyloid precursor protein family members APP and APLP2 resulting in MuSK activation. This then induces the aggregation of acetylcholine receptors (AChRs),3–5 ensuring neuromuscular synapse formation and maintenance. In other tissues, such as the kidneys, lung and muscle, agrin (splice variant: y0, z0) plays a role in mechanotransduction by linking the cell cytoskeleton to other basement membrane components including α-dystroglycan (DAG1) and laminin-γ1 (LAMC1)6 ,7 through either direct binding or indirectly through integrins.8 More recent studies with transgenic mice have demonstrated a non-redundant involvement of agrin in postnatal skeletal development and endochondral bone formation.9
The articular cartilage covers the ends of the long bones at the joint and ensures frictionless motion. Unlike the epiphyseal cartilage of the developing skeletal elements, which is destined to become calcified, invaded by vessels and ultimately replaced by bone through endochondral bone formation, the articular cartilage is permanent throughout life, is avascular and aneural and is resistant to calcification, vascular invasion and endochondral bone formation. Cartilage is mainly composed of specialised extracellular matrix (ECM) rich in collagen type II (COL2A1) and highly sulfated proteoglycans, prevalently aggrecan (ACAN), and chondrocytes which are sparsely present throughout the abundant ECM.10 Chondrocyte differentiation and expression of COL2A1 and ACAN is driven by the cartilage-specific transcription factor SOX9.11
Under resting conditions, cartilage matrix has a very low turnover (the half-life of COL2A1 is estimated to be ∼117 years12); however, following damage, the tissue deploys a homeostatic response, supported by SOX9 upregulation and activity, driving the replacement of the damaged ECM and restoring cartilage integrity.2 ,13 When this response is insufficient or stunted, ECM breakdown takes place due to the release of proteolytic enzymes including matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and aggrecanases.14 Cartilage destruction and the resulting joint failure are the hallmark of osteoarthritis (OA), the most common cause of chronic disability worldwide after cardiovascular disease.15 ,16 During OA, chondrocytes acquire a phenotype similar to the hypertrophic chondrocytes of the developing growth plate, characterised by expression of collagen type X (COL10A1) and MMP-13.17 ,18 The acquisition of this phenotype and the consequent mineralisation drive cartilage breakdown.19 Therefore, hypertrophic differentiation and calcification are important mechanisms in OA progression. In spite of the huge social and economic burden, we still have no cure for OA and strategies for cartilage regeneration represent a priority in medical research.
In this study we reveal a novel cell-autonomous reparative autocrine/paracrine circuit with great therapeutic potential that is governed by the homeostatic function of agrin in adult articular chondrocytes.
Materials and methods
Destabilisation of the medial meniscus
OA was induced in 8-week-old 129/Sv male mice by surgical destabilisation of the medial meniscus (DMM) or sham surgery to the contralateral limb as described previously20 and killed after 8 weeks.
Cartilage harvest and chondrocyte isolation
Adult human articular cartilage was obtained from patients undergoing joint replacement for knee OA after obtaining informed consent. All procedures were approved by the East London and The City Research Ethics Committee. Full thickness cartilage was dissected from preserved areas of the femoral condyles and the patellar groove. From each sample, one full thickness specimen was processed for histological grading. Bovine chondrocytes were isolated from the metatarsal joints of 18-month-old bovine obtained within 6 h of death from a local abattoir. Full thickness sections were harvested for histological analysis. Chondrocyte isolation and in vitro expansion was performed as previously described.21
The full thickness explants taken for histological scoring were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) at pH 7.4, paraffin embedded, sectioned, stained and scored for features of OA as described previously.22 ,23 All experiments were performed using freshly isolated or confluent P0 cells.
Overexpression and siRNA transfection
Subconfluent cells were transfected with a plasmid encoding agrin (COS7 and agrin plasmid were a kind gift from Dr M Ferns, UC Davis Health System, USA), green fluorescent protein (GFP), bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-2 (kind gift from Dr Gerard Gross, Signaling and Gene Regulation, Gesellschaft für Biotechnologische Forschung (GBF), Braunschweig, Germany), LRP4 or siRNAs (20 nM) by using JetPrime transfection reagent (PolyPlus Transfection, Illkirch, France) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The cells were used in monolayer or micromass. Observed transfection efficiency was 25%–30% for C28/I2 and bovine chondrocytes; and around 95% for COS7 cells. siRNA oligo sequences can be found in online supplementary table S1. A Stealth RNAi negative control duplex of low guanine-cytosine (GC) content (Invitrogen) was used as a negative control for agrin siRNA.
Micromass culture and Alcian blue staining
Cells were resuspended at a density of 2.0×107 cells/mL in complete medium, and micromass cultures were obtained by pipetting 15 µL drops of cell suspension into each well of a 24 well plate. The cells were allowed to attach for 3 h and then 1 mL of complete medium was added. Micromasses were cultured for 4 days, changing the medium every 48 h. Micromasses were harvested for RT-PCR gene expression analysis or fixed and whole-mount stained with Alcian blue.24 Alcian blue extraction and quantification was performed as previously described.25 Images were acquired at room temperature with a camera (Coolpix 4500; Nikon), with the macrosetting and daylight. Image contrast was modified with Photoshop 7.0 for best graphic rendering, equally for all treatments.
Immunocytochemistry and immunohistochemistry were performed as previously described.25 For antigen retrieval on paraffin sections we used pepsin digestion.25 The primary anti-agrin rabbit polyclonal antibody (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Dallas, Texas, USA) or the isotype-matched negative control normal rabbit IgG (Dako, Ely, Cambridgeshire, UK) was diluted 1:200 in blocking buffer. Secondary antibodies were cy3-conjugated goat anti–rabbit antibody diluted 1:300 (Jackson ImmunoResearch Laboratories, West Grove, Pennsylvania, USA) for immunocytochemistry or goat anti-rabbit antibody Alexa 555 diluted 1:300 (Life Technologies) for immunohistochemistry. Slides were mounted in Mowiol (EMD Millipore, Darmstadt, Germany), and images were acquired with a fluorescence microscope (BX61; Olympus, Southend-on-Sea, UK) using a Uplan-Fluor 40× NA 0.85 objective lens. Images were acquired by using an F-View II Soft Imaging Solutions (SIS) camera and Cell P software (Olympus). After acquisition, the contrast of the images was enhanced for best graphic rendering using Photoshop 7.0, all with the same parameters, without altering the relationship of the target to control the images.
Total RNA extraction and real-time qPCR
In vivo ectopic cartilage formation assay
The ectopic cartilage formation assay was performed as described previously.21 In brief, for each injection 5 million freshly isolated bovine chondrocytes were mixed with either 500 000 growth-arrested (treated with 7.5 µg/mL of mitomycin-C (Sigma-Aldrich) diluted in complete medium for 2 h at 37°C) COS7 cells overexpressing FL-agrin or with the same amount of mitomycin C-treated GFP transfected COS7 cells. Each sample was resuspended in 50 µL of sterile PBS and injected intramuscularly in the posterior compartment of the thigh of 3-week-old female CD1nu/nu mice.23 Twelve injections per condition (24 in total) were performed. Animals were maintained in isolator cages under an unrestricted diet. The animals were then killed after 2 weeks and the cartilage implants were retrieved. All procedures were approved by the Local Ethics committee and the UK Home Office. The implants were weighed and then paraffin embedded for histological analysis.
α-dystroglycan binding was inhibited in vitro on bovine chondrocytes in monolayer using 10 ng/mL α-dystroglycan antibody (IIH6; Santa Cruz). Binding inhibition was confirmed using Phalloidin (Invitrogen) staining in PBS 1:1000. IgM (Santa Cruz) was used as control antibody.
Parametric data were compared with a student's t test. p Values <0.05 were considered significant. *p<0.05; **p<0.005; ***p<0.0005. All the data in the graphs are expressed as mean±SEM.
Agrin (y0, z0) is expressed in the articular cartilage and is downregulated in OA
In the context of a transcriptomic analysis to identify genes regulated by mechanical injury in cartilage,2 we discovered that mRNA encoding for agrin and its receptors LRP4, APP, APLP2, DAG1 and LAMC1 were expressed in human adult articular cartilage (figure 1A) raising the question of whether agrin signalling has a role in cartilage biology. MuSK, which is essential at the neuromuscular junction, was not detected in two of three samples.
At the neuromuscular junction, the presence of the alternatively spliced inserts y and z results in a 1000-fold higher affinity of agrin to LRP4 and therefore neuromuscular synapse stability via AChR clustering.4 To investigate whether these inserts (y4:KSRK; z8:ELTNEIPA or 11:PETLDRSALFS or 19: ELTNEIPAPETLDRSALFS) were present in chondrocytes, we sequenced across the potential insert sites of agrin from human articular chondrocyte cDNA. This analysis revealed, as in other non-neural tissues, the absence of the alternatively spliced y and z inserts in chondrocytes (figure 1B), where agrin has a preferred, but not exclusive, affinity for dystroglycan binding compared with the y4, z8 isoform.26
To investigate the expression pattern of agrin in normal joints we used immunofluorescence. Agrin was abundantly detected in human, bovine and murine cartilage and menisci (figure 1C); agrin protein was retained in vitro in isolated primary bovine chondrocytes and in the human chondrocyte cell line C28/I227 in monolayer (figure 1D) and in three-dimensional culture (see online supplementary figure S1). In the mouse, agrin was detected within the superficial and deep layers of the articular cartilage, within the osteoid in the subchondral bone, and in the menisci. In healthy human and bovine cartilage agrin expression was distributed uniformly. However, in human OA cartilage, agrin expression was markedly reduced (almost undetectable) in the more severely affected areas (Mankin score >8) compared with the relatively preserved ones (Mankin score <4) (figure 1E). In a validated murine model of OA induced by surgical DMM,20 agrin expression was rapidly reduced in the articular cartilage as early as 7 days after surgery, reaching undetectable levels after 8 weeks (figure 1F).
Agrin cell autonomously regulates the chondrocyte transcription factor SOX9
The downregulation of agrin in OA cartilage prompted us to investigate whether agrin could have a function in chondrocyte differentiation and ECM formation. To investigate whether agrin has a cell-autonomous function in chondrocytes we applied a loss of function approach. Silencing agrin in C28/I2 chondrocytes using either of two independent siRNA oligonucleotide pairs (siRNA-1 and siRNA-2), we obtained a reduction of agrin mRNA by 59% and 78% respectively, allowing dose–response experiments (figure 2A). Agrin knockdown resulted in a dose-dependent decrease of absolute sulfated glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content in C28/I2 micromass cultures as evaluated by Alcian blue staining24 (figure 2B). Total DNA content was not changed, thereby suggesting that such difference did not result from a decreased cell number (figure 2C).
Agrin silencing also resulted in reduced expression of the cartilage transcription factor SOX9 mRNA (figure 2D) and dose-dependent downregulation of its transcriptional targets COL2A1 and ACAN mRNA (figure 2E, F).
Conversely, overexpression of full length agrin (y0, z0) in bovine primary chondrocytes resulted in significantly increased sulfated GAG content compared with GFP-transfected controls, both as total amount per micromass (figure 3A) and when normalised for DNA content (figure 3B). Moreover, after 5 days culture, SOX9 mRNA was significantly upregulated and 2 days later so were its direct transcriptional targets COL2A1 and ACAN (figure 3C–E).28
These data also demonstrate that agrin function is cell autonomous as it takes place in vitro, in the absence of potential exogenous sources of agrin (eg, nerves).
Exogenous agrin supports formation of stable, hyaline-like cartilage in vivo
In vitro cartilage formation is not always predictive of cartilage formation in vivo.29 For instance, mesenchymal stem cells can form cartilage in vitro, yet fail to form stable cartilage tissue in vivo even following in vitro differentiation.29 To confirm the anabolic function of agrin in vivo, we used a highly stringent transplantation model in which bovine articular chondrocytes form stable hyaline cartilage resistant to vascular invasion and endochondral bone formation when injected ectopically, in suspension, into the muscle of immunodeficient mice.23 ,29 This validated model predicts clinical efficacy of cell preparations for cartilage repair in humans,30 and allows robust quantification and monitoring of gene expression.23
In order to administer exogenous agrin to the implanted chondrocytes for the entire duration of the assay we used a previously validated strategy4 based on co-implantation of growth-arrested, agrin-overexpressing COS7 cells (ratio 10:1) or with GFP-overexpressing COS7 cells as control (see online supplementary figure S3). Two weeks after implantation, the implants exposed to agrin were significantly larger than those exposed to GFP (figure 4A–C) as determined by histomorphometry (figure 4A, B) and wet weight (figure 4C) and with a larger differentiated area as determined by increased area of Safranin O metachromatic staining (figure 4A, D), but without evidence of excessive accumulation of proteoglycans (figure 4E). Similar data were obtained using toluidine blue staining (figure 4H). No vascular invasion was detected with Masson's trichrome staining and no calcification was detected with alizarin red staining (figure 4I, J). Gene expression analysis performed with bovine-specific primers showed no increased expression of COL10A1 and MMP-13 in the agrin-treated group compared with control (figure 4F, G).
Agrin-induced upregulation of SOX9 is α-dystroglycan and LRP4 dependent
At the neuromuscular junction, neuronal agrin (y4, z8) binds to LRP4 and signals through MuSK, while in muscle cells, non-neuronal agrin (y0, z0) links the cytoskeleton to the basement membrane through binding α-dystroglycan.31 ,32 Therefore we investigated which of these two mechanisms was engaged for the anabolic functions of agrin in chondrocytes. Treatment with an antibody which blocks the interaction of α-dystroglycan with agrin4 ,33 abrogated agrin-induced upregulation of SOX9 (figure 5A). Surprisingly, also LRP4 silencing by siRNA completely inhibited agrin-induced SOX9 upregulation (figure 5B), suggesting that both LRP4 and α-dystroglycan are required for agrin-induced chondrocyte differentiation.
The requirement of LRP4 is unexpected because the (y0, z0) variant of agrin has low affinity for LRP4 and a reduced capacity for clustering the AChR at the neuromuscular junction.34 However, overexpression of LRP4 alone also induced SOX9 expression in primary bovine chondrocytes (figure 5C), in keeping with a previous report in ATDC5 cells.35 This and the fact that deficiency of LRP4 result in a skeletal phenotype36 support a role for LRP4 in chondrocytic differentiation. Interestingly, the overexpression or silencing of agrin in chondrocytes did not regulate the mRNA expression of LRP4 (figure 5D, E).
We have discovered that the (y0, z0) isoform of agrin is expressed in the adult articular cartilage and is downregulated in OA. We showed that agrin has an anabolic function in maintaining chondrocyte differentiation and enhancing ECM production in vitro and in vivo without inducing chondrocyte hypertrophy or endochondral bone formation. We have found that agrin-induced chondrocyte differentiation requires a unique receptor/coreceptor repertoire including both α-dystroglycan and LRP4 in articular chondrocytes.
Agrin function at the neuromuscular synapse requires the binding of LRP4 and, indirectly, MuSK,3 ,5 ,37 whereas the function of agrin in muscle cells is mediated by its binding to α-dystroglycan and laminin. It is thought that the differential binding to these different receptor complexes is dependent on the presence of the spliced inserts y and z, which confer high affinity for LRP4.26 ,38 In particular, structural data of the agrin–LRP4–MuSK complex revealed that the z8 loop of rat neuronal agrin was responsible for the primary agrin-LRP4 interaction, preceding the formation of the tetramer in which two agrin–LRP4 heterodimers interact and for MuSK-dependent signalling at the neuromuscular junction.39 However, we previously showed that the engagement of the coreceptors APP and APLP2 (also expressed by chondrocytes—figure 1A) can independently interact with the z0 form of agrin as well as with LRP4,3 to either stabilise the interaction of agrin with LRP4 or indirectly recruit LRP4 into a larger agrin signalling complex and thereby support its biological function as a BMP and WNT (Wingless type MMTV integration site family member) signal modulator.40 Taken together, these data suggest that an extended cell surface receptor repertoire regulates the affinity of agrin for different receptors and the interplay with other signalling pathways including BMPs and WNTs to fine-tune biological specificity in the maintenance of articular cartilage.
In the skeletal context, as hypothesised in figure 6, LRP4 appears to modulate and coordinate fundamental signalling pathways including WNTs and BMPs. While both these pathways are essential for the homeostasis and integrity of cartilage throughout life,41–44 their excessive/inappropriate activation drives cartilage breakdown.45 ,46 In humans, single nucleotide polymorphisms in genes involved in the WNT and BMP pathways are associated with predisposition to develop OA.47 ,48 This modulation/coordination may take place through a multitude of potential mechanisms including LRP4 acting as a receptor for the WNT and BMP inhibitors sclerostin33 and Wise,40 as well as the WNT inhibitor Dickkopf (DKK)-1,33 competing with the WNT coreceptors LRP5 and LRP6 and with the intracellular WNT machinery. The overexpression of LRP4 alone in primary articular chondrocytes was sufficient to increase the expression of SOX9 (figure 5C) in primary chondrocytes, supported chondrogenic differentiation and inhibited WNT signalling in the ATDC5 cell line;35 in vivo, mice carrying a hypomorphic LRP4 allele developed a significant skeletal phenotype.33 ,36
The identification of a specific coreceptor repertoire and of a specific agonist, agrin, capable of promoting the formation of phenotypically stable hyaline-like cartilage resistant to vascular invasion and endochondral bone formation in vivo, is a unique therapeutic opportunity in cartilage-regenerative medicine and in the field of OA and opens a new exciting avenue of investigation to understand how high specificity of a biological effect is achieved by modulating otherwise pleiotropic signalling pathways.
We thank Dr M Ferns (UC Davis Health System, USA) for providing the Agrin plasmid and Dr G Gross (Signaling and Gene Regulation, Gesellschaft für Biotechnologische Forschung (GBF), Braunschweig, Germany) for providing the BMP-2 plasmid; Mr Y Pengas, Mr P Achan and Mr M Ramachandran for the supply of human knee samples (Barts and the London National Health Service Trust, London, England, UK). We thank Dr Mary Goldring for the C28/I2 cell line.
Handling editor Tore K Kvien
MP and FD'A are co-senior authors.
Contributors SE, FD, KV-G, PK, GN and MP designed the experiments, analysed the data and prepared the manuscript. Experimental work was performed by SE, with contributions from GN, HI and KV-G. FD, MR, JH, AN, PK, MP and CP contributed to experimental design and writing of the manuscript.
Funding We gratefully acknowledge funding support of this work by the MRC (MR/L022893/1, MR/K013076/1 and G1000403-2/1), Arthritis Research UK (19654 and 20205), the Rosetrees Trust (A589) and NIH grant R37 HL63762 (to JH), the American Health Assistance Foundation, the Consortium for Frontotemporal Dementia Research, the Bright Focus Foundation, the Lupe Murchison Foundation and The Ted Nash Long Life Foundation.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Obtained.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.