Objectives: To assess the impact of increased number of diagnostic and therapeutic joint procedures on the incidence and type of septic arthritis (SA).
Methods: All cases of SA in Iceland from 1990–2002 were identified by thorough review of the available medical information. The results of synovial fluid cultures from every microbiology department in Iceland were checked and positive culture results reviewed, as well as patient charts with a discharge diagnosis of septic arthritis (International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD) code M009).
Results: A total of 253 cases of SA (69 children and 184 adults) were diagnosed in Iceland in 1990–2002, giving an average incidence of 7.1 cases/100 000 inhabitants. The incidence of SA increased from 4.2 cases/100 000 in 1990 to 11.0 cases/100 000 in 2002. This rise in SA was primarily observed in adults where the incidence rose by 0.61 cases/100 000 per year (p<0.001). SA was iatrogenic in 41.8% of adults and the number of iatrogenic infections increased from 2.8 cases/year in 1990–1994 to 9.0 cases/year in 1998–2002 (p<0.01). The annual number of arthroscopies increased from 430 in 1990–1994 to 2303 in 1998–2002 (p<0.001) and there was a correlation between the total usage of intra-articular drugs in Iceland and the incidence of SA (p<0.01). The frequency of post-arthroscopy SA was 0.14% and post-arthrocentesis SA 0.037%.
Conclusions: The incidence of SA has increased in recent years due to an increased number of arthroscopies and joint injections. Although the frequency of SA per procedure has not changed, these results emphasise the importance of sterile technique and firm indications for joint procedures.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Septic arthritis (SA) due to bacterial infection is a serious and potentially life threatening disease that can lead to rapid destruction of the vulnerable articular hyaline cartilage and irreversible loss of joint function.1 2 The reported incidence of septic arthritis is 2–6 cases/100 000 inhabitants.3–7 Advancing age, rheumatoid arthritis (RA), osteoarthritis, immunosuppressive therapies and diabetes mellitus have been identified as the main risk factors for idiopathic septic arthritis. Iatrogenic infection resulting from joint surgeries, arthroscopies and needle insertions into joints is another source of septic arthritis. In recent years, the number of arthroscopies has greatly increased as well as the number of joint injections due to the emergence of intra-articular viscosupplementation therapies. The risk of procedure-related SA has been estimated at 0.5–2.0% for arthroscopies8–12 and 0.005–0.0002% for joint injections.13–15 In light of the growing number of individuals with one or more risk factors for SA, the incidence would be expected to be rising. However, very few of these studies have addressed this issue and most published studies are derived from selected populations. Therefore a retrospective, nationwide study was carried out to examine the incidence, cause and characteristics of septic arthritis in Iceland over a 13-year period.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Clinical setting and definition of cases
Over a 13-year period from 1 January 1990 to 31 December 2002 a nationwide computerised and manual survey for culture positive joint fluids was performed in all microbiology laboratories in Iceland. In addition, medical records and archives at all hospitals that admit patients with SA were searched for the discharge diagnosis of bacterial arthritis (M009 according to the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD)-9 and ICD-10 codes).
Hospital medical records were reviewed and clinical and laboratory data collected in a systematic manner. Iatrogenic SA was defined as occurring within 2 weeks after arthrocentesis or arthroscopy, or within 6 months after open joint surgery. The total number of arthroscopic and arthrocentesis procedures 1990–2002 were available from computerised records at the State Social Security Institute (SSI), which is the only agency in Iceland that reimburses for ambulatory medical procedures. The total import and sales of corticosteroids for intra-articular injections (methyl prednisolone (DepoMedrol; Pfizer NewYork, NewYork, USA), betamethasone (Diprospan; Schering-Plough, Kenilworth, New Jersey, USA) and triamcinolone (Lederspan; Meda AB, Solna, Sweden)) and for hyaluronic acid preparations (Hyalgan, Artzal Astra-Zeneca, Albertslund, Denmark) were similarily obtained from the SSI. Defined daily doses (DDD) for all drugs were obtained from the World Health Organization (WHO) Collaborating Centre for Drug Statistics Methodology (WHOCC). The study was approved by the Data Protection Authorities in Iceland and the National Bioethics Committee.
The age-specific incidence of infectious arthritis during the period 1990–2002 (yearly and total) was obtained by dividing the number of cases by the mean population number for each gender in each 10-year age interval (the first 2 years and 2–9 years of life were computed separately). The age-standardised incidence was computed using the global population figure as reference. The same approach was used for obtaining the standardised values for ages 0–16 and >16 years using a truncated global population figure as reference. Regression analysis was performed for the age-standardised incidence for each gender. Linear regression was first used for finding the linear time trend and then quadratic regression was used to find whether the time trend was changing with time. The association of yearly use of intra-articular drugs (DDD/1000 inhabitants) and number of septic arthritis cases was analysed with linear regression with and without adjusting for common time trend.
The same approach was used for analysing the association of number of procedures involving joints and the number of septic arthritis cases during the period 1990–2002. The level of significance used was p<0.05. All tests were two-tailed. The χ2 test with Yates correction for continuity was used for comparison between two groups using SigmaStat for Windows software, V.3.11 (SigmaStat, Systat Software GmbH, Erkath, Germany).
Incidence of septic arthritis
From 1990 to 2002 a total of 253 cases of bacterial arthritis were diagnosed in Iceland, of which 159 were males and 94 females, giving an average incidence of 7.1 cases/100 000 inhabitants. Additionally, five cases of atypical mycobacterial joint infections were identified. These cases were not included in the overall analysis of SA. There were 69 children (0–16 years old) diagnosed with SA, 37 of those less than 2 years of age. Figure 1 shows age- and gender-specific incidence rates of SA for children 0–24 months old, ⩾2–10 years old and subsequent 10-year age groups. As shown in fig 1, women had lower incidence rates than men in all age groups (male/female ratio 1.7). For both sexes, the rate of SA rose sharply after the age of 50. Among children less than 2 years of age the age adjusted incidence was quite high at 27/100 000.
Change in the incidence of septic arthritis 1990–2002
The annual total number of cases of SA for children 0–16 years and for adults are shown in fig 2. The annual incidence of SA increased progressively from 4.2 per 100 000 in 1990 to 11.0 per 100 000 inhabitants in 2002. This change was primarily due to increased number of SA cases in adults and was statistically significant by linear trend, which showed a yearly increase of 0.61 adult cases per 100 000 (p<0.001). The mean annual incidence during the first 5 years (1990–94) increased from 4.2 cases per 100 000 adult inhabitants to 9.4 per 100 000 adults in 1998–2002 (95% CI 3.2–5.5 and 7.9–11.1, respectively; p<0.01).
Iatrogenic septic arthritis
Joint infections were iatrogenic in 1.4% (1/69 cases) of children and 41.8% (77/184 cases) of adults. Iatrogenic infections in adults were due to open joint surgery in 26 cases (14.1% of total), arthroscopy in 18 cases (9.8%) and arthrocentesis in 33 cases (17.9%) (table 1). The mean number of iatrogenic infections increased from 2.8 infections/year in 1990–1994 to 9.0 infections/year in 1998–2002 (p<0.01) and this was the main reason for the observed increase in SA during the study period. The overall percentage of iatrogenic infections was similar in young adults (age 17–65) and older adults (age ⩾65). Septic arthritis due to arthrocentesis was common in both age groups but post arthroscopy SA was primarily observed in the younger adults (15/101 vs 3/83; p = 0,02) whereas infections due to open surgery were more common in the older adults (18/83 vs 8/101; p = 0.01).
To determine whether the rising incidence of SA was related to increased number of diagnostic or therapeutic joint procedures, information about the total number of arthroscopies and arthrocentesis were obtained from the SSI in Iceland (table 2). The annual number of documented arthrocentesis was only available for the practice of rheumatology and orthopaedics, but not for general practitioners. We were, however, able to retrieve accurate information about the annual sales of intra-articular glucocorticoid and hyaluronan preparations for 1990–2002. There was a correlation between the usage of intra-articular betamethasone (Diprospan®; p = 0.001), hyaluronic acid (p = 0.02), and the total usage of intra-articular drugs (p = 0.008) and the incidence of SA (table 2). The number of reimbursed arthrocentesis procedures performed by rheumatologists and orthopaedists did not change markedly over the study period, but the number of arthroscopies increased from an annual mean of 430 arthroscopies in 1990–1994 to 2303 arthroscopies in 1998–2002 (p<0.001).
Clinical and microbiological characteristics of septic arthritis
The clinical characteristics of SA in children (0–2 years vs >2–16 years old) and adults (16–65 years vs >65 years old) are shown in table 3. No significant difference in joint distribution was observed between younger and older adults, although shoulder infections appeared to be more common in the elderly (13.8% vs 4.8%, p = 0.05). In adults, SA was polyarticular in 3.3% of cases.
Compared to adults the relative occurrence of SA of the hip was significantly higher in children (35.5% vs 13.7% respectively, p<0.001).
The median temperature on admission was 38–38.1°C in all age groups. Normal temperatures (<37.8°C) were quite frequent, seen in about one fourth of children and almost half of the adults (table 3). Similarily, peripheral white blood cell (WBC) count was normal (<10 000/μl) on admission in 26% of children and 46% of adults. Normal values for temperature and WBC count on admission were more common in adults (p = 0.066 and p = 0.05 respectively). Normal erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and C-reactive protein (CRP) values were infrequent and only 2.3% of children and 4.4% of adults had normal values for ESR and CRP on admission.
Synovial fluid was obtained in 97.4% of cases (98.6% of children, 97.3% of adults). Results from synovial fluid analysis are shown in table 3. Although the leukocyte count was markedly elevated (median = 58 100/mm3) a relatively low synovial fluid leukocyte count (<20 000/mm3) was observed in 7% of children and 15% of adults. Synovial fluid culture was positive in 84% of adults but only in 54% of children. Blood cultures were obtained in 96% (66/69) of children and in 74% (137/184) of adults. They were positive in one quarter to one third of individuals tested, arguably more often in the elderly (41%, p = 0.056). Positive Gram stain and/or blood culture increased the positively identified septic arthritis cases considerably, from 54% to 61% in children and from 84% to 88% in adults. The yield of synovial fluid culture was significantly lower in adult patients who had received antibiotics prior to diagnostic joint aspiration (10/27 negative, 37%) compared to patients without antibiotic exposure (15/119 negative, 12.6%; p = 0.002).
The contributing risk factors for SA among adults were history of a recent trauma to the involved joint in 24% of cases, osteoarthritis in 19%, diabetes mellitus (DM) in 7% all having type II DM and being treated with per oral hypoglycaemic drugs, rheumatoid arthritis in 4% all being treated with methotrexate, neoplasia in 2% and one patient was HIV positive. Additionally, three patients were receiving glucocorticoids. In 16 (8.7%) of the adult cases SA was due to infected prosthetic joints, 12 knees, 3 hip joints and 1 shoulder joint.
The type and frequency of bacterial organisms is shown in table 4.
A total of 33 of the adult cases were not identified by positive joint fluid culture, and of those, 4 had positive Gram stain of joint fluid and 4 had positive blood cultures. In all, 32 (46%) children were not identified by positive joint fluid culture, but one of those had positive Gram stain of joint fluid and three had positive blood culture. The clinical and laboratory characteristics of children and adults with SA diagnosed without positive joint fluid culture was similar to the culture positive SA. Specifically, median age, sex and joint involvement were comparable, as well as ESR, CRP and synovial fluid leukocyte count, duration of antibiotic therapy and hospital stay (data not shown).
Of the 254 patients, 5 died in the hospital, (mean age, 70 years); 3 following infection with Staphylococcus aureus, 1 after pneumococcal infection, and 1 following streptococcal infection. The mortality rate was 1.8% when calculated from all cases of septic arthritis but 2,7% if limited to the adult population.
From 1990–2002 we identified five cases of arthritis due to mycobacteria other than tuberculosis; two Mycobacterium kansasii, two Mycobacterium avium-intracellulare and one Mycobacterium marinum infection. These infections affected three elbows and two wrists joints in four men and one woman, 34–49 years old. One of these patients was HIV positive but the other four had no identifiable immunodeficiency. These mycobacterial infections were not included in the overall analysis of the data.
In this paper we report a markedly increased rate of joint infections in adults in Iceland from 1990 to 2002. During the study period there was a mean annual increase of 0.61 cases/100 000 adult inhabitants. The incidence of 4.2 cases/100 000 adults in 1990–1994 is similar to the reported number in other studies3–6 16 but the incidence of 9.4/100 000 adults during 1998–2002 is considerably higher and statistically different (p<0.01). This change is primarily due to increase in iatrogenic infections following joint arthroscopies and arthrocentesis. It coincides with marked increase in the registered number of joint arthroscopies in Iceland and increased use of intra-articular steroids and joint-viscous supplements in Iceland during these years. However, this increase in SA following joint injections was not due to a higher number of arthrocentesis procedures performed by rheumatologists and orthopaedists. However, the increased use of intra-articular steroids and joint-viscous supplements suggests that the number of arthrocentesis procedures did indeed increase during this observational period. That scenario could be explained by higher numbers of arthrocentesis procedures being performed by other doctors. This is however purely speculative, since computerised documentation of arthrocentesis in primary care is mostly unavailable. Septic arthritis due to open joint surgeries did not increase over this time period.
The frequency of post-arthroscopic SA has been reported 0.1–0.5% at specific medical centres9–12 but to our knowledge this frequency has not been previously estimated based on a nationwide analysis. The estimated frequency in Iceland of 0.14% is similar to these previous reports.
There is very limited data available in the medical literature about the actual risk of SA following arthrocentesis. In early reports this risk was estimated at 0.005 to 0.0002% per arthrocentesic procedure.13–15 These percentages are lower than can be estimated from our study. According to the SSI registry in Iceland the total number of documented ambulatory arthrocentesis in Iceland performed by rheumatologists and orthopaedists is 6900 per year (table 2). Additionally, an estimated maximum of 1000 arthrocentesis procedures are performed annually by general practitioners (L. Ólafsson, the Center of Health Care in Reykjavik, Iceland personal communication). Accordingly, the estimated risk of septic arthritis following arthrocentesis in Iceland is 3 infections/7900 procedures, or 0.037% per injection. Compared to other commonly performed procedures, an incidence of 0.037% per injection is not high. However, given the significant morbidity and 10–15% mortality previously reported in SA3–6 16 it is of utmost importance to avoid unnecessary infectious complications and to perform arthrocentesis according to the best standard of practice.
In our study 17,9% of SA in adults occurred post-arthrocentesis, which is alarmingly high compared to the frequency of 1.9–3% in previous studies.4 6 7 It has been suggested that intra-articular steroid17 or hyaluronan18 injection may increase the risk of joint infection. Thus, the generally increased use of steroids and hyaluronans in Iceland (table 2) may explain the increased incidence of SA in Iceland.
Presumably organisms frequently enter the joint during arthrocentesis. Skin fragments introduced into the joint during arthrocentesis contained bacterial genes (by polymerase chain reaction) one third of the time.19 and despite standard sterilisation of the skin surface, organisms could be cultured from needle tips in 14–28% of events.20 The best standard of practice for arthrocentesis has not been thoroughly studied and method of sterilisation varies considerably among doctors;21 alcohol swabs, pivodone iodine and chlorhexidine have been used in different reports, all apparently with satisfactory results, although chlorhexidine arguably has the edge over the other two methods. Chlorhexidine resulted in better sterilisation of needle tips compared to alcohol swabs20 and chlorhexidine use yielded significantly lower skin pathogen contamination of blood cultures compared with pivodone iodine.22 It may also be of practical importance in the clinical settings that full bacteriocidal effects from pivodone iodine takes over 1 min to develop.22 As far as we know, all three types of antiseptic techniques are in use in Iceland but no survey has been conducted to assess their prevalence among doctors. We were not able to correlate the type of antiseptic technique used to the rate of SA in this retrospective study. Irrespective of this, a panel of experts from the American College of Rheumatology emphasised that intra-articular corticosteroid injections are “safe and effective when administered by an experienced doctor”.23 This may indeed be the most important factor in avoiding iatrogenic SA following arthrocentesis.
The clinical characteristics of SA have been previously reported in children24–28 adults,3–6 in the elderly;29–32 and numerous reviews have been published on septic arthritis.33–36 Most previous studies in adults have been derived from selected regions or populations, although one report represented a whole communal region.5 The current report is the first study reporting a nationwide survey. We screened all microbiology laboratories in Iceland for positive joint fluid cultures, and all hospitals in Iceland for ICD-9 and-10 discharge diagnoses of bacterial arthritis. Our study has numerous clinical and laboratory findings similar to previous reports. Thus, the sex ratio of 1.7 (male/female), risk factors (including advancing age, RA, osteoarthritis (OA), DM, iatrogenic illness), joint involvement and pathogens cultured are quite comparable to these reports. In our study, the frequency of polyarticular involvement among adults was quite low (3.3%) compared to 8.4–19.5% in other studies7 8 and mortality among adults was only 2.7%, considerably lower than reported in most studies,3–6 19although similar to some.29 Our study agrees with previous findings that markers of systemic inflammation (fever, leukocytosis, elevated ESR or CRP) can be normal on presentation in SA. In fact normal temperature, WBC count, ESR and CRP were observed in 42%, 46%, 12% and 15%, respectively, in adults (table 3). Furthermore, although SA is usually associated with high synovial leukocyte count we observed counts less than 20 000 in 15% of adult cases. Our study emphasises the importance of obtaining blood cultures as well as synovial fluid cultures, and highlights the potential for false negative results if the patient has received oral antibiotics prior to obtaining cultures. Thus, the diagnosis of SA in adults according to our study should primarily be derived from thorough medical history and physical examination, supported by joint fluid WBC analysis and confirmed by synovial/blood cultures in 88% cases. Antibiotic exposure prior to synovial culture may decrease the culture yield to 63%.
Surprisingly, 39% of children with clinical picture of septic arthritis had negative synovial fluid and blood cultures. The clinical and laboratory characteristics were similar in culture positive and negative children. These results are identical to numerous other reports24–28 and to date no reasonable explanation has been put forward.
In summary, the incidence of septic arthritis has markedly increased in recent years due to increased number of arthroscopies and therapeutic joint injections. Although the frequency of SA per procedure has not changed, these results emphasise the importance of sterile technique and firm indications for diagnostic and therapeutic joint procedures.
We thank Helgi Sigvaldason for statistical assistance and to Dr Magnús Gottfredsson for reviewing the manuscript.
Funding: This study was suppported by a grant from the Wyeth Rheumatology Foundation of Iceland.
Competing interests: None declared.
Ethics approval: The study was approved by the Data Protection Authorities in Iceland and the National Bioethics Committee.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.