Table 5

 Agreement between the three clinicians about diagnosis of affected arm

DiagnosisPrevalence (%)†κ Value
ConsultantSpec regNurseCons/spec regCons/nurseSpec reg/nurse
*p<0.05, **p<0.01; †prevalence is the percentage of affected shoulders which were found to test positive; ‡McNemar p<0.05 denoting significant difference in prevalence between the two raters.
Rotator cuff diagnosis (undifferentiated)72 (n = 153)82 (n = 158)82 (n = 159)0.46**‡0.41**‡0.38**
Impingement49 (n = 156)69 (n = 159)66 (n = 159)0.39**‡0.16*‡0.43**
Acromioclavicular joint15 (n = 156)27 (n = 159)46 (n = 159)0.24**‡0.17**‡0.29**‡
Adhesive capsulitis/GHOA19 (n = 156)23 (n = 159)33 (n = 159)0.77**0.26**‡0.30**‡
Referred pain12 (n = 156)7 (n = 159)14 (n = 159)0.56**‡0.43**0.30**‡