Article Text


Does the prevalence of radiographic hand osteoarthritis in patients with HIV-1 infection increase or not?
  1. Wei Luo,
  2. Guang-hua Lei,
  3. Hong-bo He,
  4. Yu-sheng Li
  1. Department of Orthopaedics, Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, Changsha, Hunan, China
  1. Correspondence to Dr Yu-sheng Li, Department of Orthopaedics, Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, Xiangya Road, Changsha, Hunan 410008, China; lys0209{at}

Statistics from

Hand osteoarthritis (HOA) is a heterogeneous disease with the involvement of different joints and varying levels of symptoms. Recent studies showed that the prevalence of HOA varied with gender, age and different hand joints.1–3 Different prevalence and longitudinal course of radiographic, erosive and symptomatic HOA were also described in the general population.2 Nevertheless, the accurate influence factors of HOA prevalence are still far from well understood. We read with deep interest the article by Anne-Laurence Tomi et al4 related to the prevalence and severity of radiographic HOA in patients with HIV-1 infection associated with metabolic syndrome. This cross-sectional Metabolic Syndrome and Fibrosis–Osteoarthritis (METAFIB-OA) study suggested that HOA frequency was greater in patients with HIV-1 infection than the general population, and it was more significant in those with metabolic syndrome (MetS). Thus, the authors thought that HIV-1 infection represents a special promotion for radiographic HOA and that there should be a ‘HIV-related OA’ subtype beyond classical OA phenotypes. We really appreciate the work that has been done by the authors. However, some worthwhile issues need further exploration.

First of all, this study did not analyse the general risk factors of HOA. As a prevalent disorder, HOA is not one single disease, but a heterogeneous group of disorders.1–3 ,5 The prevalence of HOA showed great variation, which may be due to differences in the types of populations and/or risk factors such as genetic background or environmental exposures across cohorts.2 ,5 ,6 To date, studies showed many factors related to HOA, including age, sex, populations, lifestyle, inflammation, bone mineral density, atherosclerosis, cardiovascular disease and metabolic health.1–3 ,5–10 This study was a cross-sectional single-centre study with only 301 effective patients included in France. On one hand, the sample was too small to exclude any other factors promoting HOA apart from MetS. On the other hand, there might be a huge difference about populations and lifestyle between patients in METAFIB-OA study and the Framingham study of the USA, which was used as general population control group. The authors declared that there was not any available HOA assessment in a population-based cohort in France; so, they used the Framingham study. We agree with the authors' point of view. But these factors might affect the accuracy of their results to a large extent.

Second, one objective of the study was to compare the prevalence in patients with HIV-1 infection with the general population. The authors measured many HIV-1 infection features such as duration of HIV infection, ultrasensitive HIV viral load, duration of exposure to protease inhibitors, CD4 level, CD4/CD8 ratio, plasma high-sensitivity C reactive protein (hsCRP) level, plasma interleukin 6 level, plasma-soluble CD14 (sCD14) level and plasma-soluble CD163 (sCD163) level, and tried to find their association with HOA. However, no factor related to HOA was found except plasma sCD14 level. What was more, this association became non-significant (OR=3.9, 95% CI 0.9 to 17.2; p=0.07) as well after adjustment for MetS. So it is hard to draw a conclusion that HIV-1 infection was a determinant of HOA. The authors also found that radiographic HOA was significantly more frequent in patients with MetS than those without it (64.5% vs 46.3%; p=0.002), but similar results were reported recently in general population studies too.9 ,10 The role of HIV-1 infection in this pathological process is still a controversial issue, which needs further research.

Finally, only 36 female patients were included in this study, and the prevalence of HOA had no statistic difference between the METAFIB women and Framingham women. While the study showed there were more than 3.5-fold higher rates on risk of HOA in women aged 50–60 years when compared with men of similar age.1 This difference might change as more female patients are being brought into study. But deficiency of female patients might have led to the bias of the results. Besides, two different readers scored the radiographs in the study. However, the inter-reader concordance for the total Kellgren-Lawrence scale was only 0.64 (95% CI 0.61 to 0.67) as described in the article. This low inter-reader reliability might affect the results. Moreover, according to the materials, HOA prevalence should be 55.5% (167/301) in all patients with HIV-1 infection, while it was 55.6% in the Abstract; HOA prevalence in HIV-1 positive patients with MetS (HIV-1+MetS+) should be 64.5% (98/152), while it was 64.7% and 64.4% in the Abstract and Table 2, respectively. When considering men within each age group, HOA frequency was 57.8% (148/256) in patients with HIV-1 infection, while it was 55.8% in the Abstract and Table 3. Diabetes was defined as glycaemia >6 mmol/L in Table 1, but it was defined as glycaemia >7 mmol/L in Table 4. These need to be corrected.

We respect the great contributions of the authors, and we would also be very interested in the authors' response regarding the above issues.


View Abstract


  • Twitter Follow Hong-bo He at

  • Contributors WL, Y-sL: concept, writing; G-hL, H-bH: concept, revising.

  • Funding This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China (grant number 81401838, 81402224).

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; internally peer reviewed.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Linked Articles