Article Text

PDF

Muscle strength, pain, and disease activity explain individual subdimensions of the Health Assessment Questionnaire disability index, especially in women with rheumatoid arthritis
  1. A Häkkinen1,
  2. H Kautiainen3,
  3. P Hannonen2,
  4. J Ylinen1,
  5. H Mäkinen2,
  6. T Sokka2,4
  1. 1Departments of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Jyväskylä Central Hospital, Jyväskylä, Finland
  2. 2Department of Medicine, Jyväskylä Central Hospital
  3. 3Rheumatism Foundation Hospital, Heinola, Finland
  4. 4Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA
  1. Correspondence to:
    Dr Arja Häkkinen
    Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Jyväskylä Central Hospital, 40620 Jyväskylä, Finland; arja.hakkinen{at}ksshp.fi

Abstract

Objective: To study the extent to which muscle strength and performance, pain, and disease activity are associated with the total Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) disability index and its subdimensions in male and female patients with rheumatoid arthritis.

Methods: HAQ for functional capacity was completed by 135 patients with rheumatoid arthritis referred for orthopaedic surgery (74% women; mean (SD) age 62 (10) years; disease duration 19 (13) years, 70% positive for rheumatoid factor). Knee extension, trunk extension and flexion, grip strength, walking speed, and sit-to-stand test were measured to mirror physical function. Radiographs of hands and feet, pain, and the modified 28 joint disease activity score (DAS28) were also assessed.

Results: Mean total HAQ was 1.08 (0.68) in women and 0.67 (0.70) in men (p = 0.0031). Women had greater disability than men in five of the eight subdimensions of the HAQ. Grip strength was 48%, knee extension strength 46%, trunk extension strength 54%, and trunk flexion strength 43% lower in women than in men. Knee extension strength was inversely correlated with walking time (r = −0.63 (95% confidence interval, −0.73 to −0.51)) and with sit-to-stand test (r = −0.47 (−0.60 to −0.31)). In an ordered logistic regression analysis in female rheumatoid patients, DAS28, pain, knee extension strength, and grip strength were associated with the total HAQ disability index.

Conclusions: Women reported greater disability than men both in the total HAQ and in the majority of its eight subdimensions. In addition to disease activity and pain, muscle strength has a major impact on disability especially in female rheumatoid patients.

  • ARA, American Rheumation Association
  • DAS28, 28 joint disease activity score
  • HAQ, Health Assessment Questionnaire
  • VAS, visual analogue scale
  • Health Assessment Questionnaire
  • disability
  • muscle strength
  • rheumatoid arthritis

Statistics from Altmetric.com

After reaching a peak in early adult years, skeletal muscle gradually declines beginning at about 45 years.1–4 Linked to the age related decrease in muscle mass, which is commonly referred sarcopenia, is a reduction in muscle strength.5–9 Rall and Roubenoff10 have reported that inflammation in rheumatoid arthritis leads to loss of metabolically active tissue, and fat mass tends to increase. This situation, termed “rheumatoid cachexia”, may aggravate the condition and lead to physical inactivity, diminished strength, and decreased functional status. Muscle weakness is a common sign in rheumatoid arthritis. Compared with healthy controls, reductions of 25–50% in muscle strength in rheumatoid patients in American Rheumation Association (ARA) functional class II have been found.11–13 In more severe rheumatoid arthritis, reductions in muscle strength of up to 70% have been reported.14 Muscle weakness is usually considered to be a result of disuse atrophy, because patients’ normal activities are impeded by systemic inflammation as well as by joint pain and by the damage characteristic of rheumatoid arthritis.

Several studies have show that the total HAQ score reflects disease activity, and is associated with pain, swollen and tender joint counts, and laboratory measures mirroring inflammatory activity.15–17 To a lesser extent, the HAQ is also associated with radiographic damage of joints.15,16,18,19 While associations of various clinical variables with HAQ have usually been reported, little is known about the influence of muscle performance on the HAQ. Stucki et al have reported a significant correlation between HAQ and muscle strength index measured by a hand held pull gauge.20 As the HAQ assesses fine movements of the upper extremities, locomotor activities of the lower extremities, and activities involving both the upper and lower extremities and the trunk, the contributions of the different muscle groups to physical function measured by the HAQ need to be studied separately.

Our aim in this study was therefore to explore in more detail the associations of muscle strength and muscle performance measured by walking speed and sit-to-stand tests with the total HAQ disability index and its subdimensions in male and female patients with longstanding rheumatoid arthritis.

METHODS

From among 194 patients with rheumatoid arthritis who had been referred to the waiting list for orthopaedic surgery at Jyväskylä Central Hospital, serving a population of 265 000, 135 volunteered for the present study and were referred to a physiotherapist for measurement of physical function. The mean (SD) age of the patients was 62 (10) years and 100 (74%) of them were female. At the check up visit 82% of the patients were being treated with disease modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs). Low dose prednisolone was employed in 42% and pain relieving drugs (at least once or twice a week) in 73%. Of the women, 28% were waiting for upper extremity surgery, 58% for lower extremity surgery, and 14% for other surgery. In men the corresponding figures were 37%, 43%, and 20%. However, not all the surgical interventions were for rheumatoid arthritis.

Functional status in the activities of daily living was assessed by the Finnish version of the HAQ,21 which included 20 questions in eight subdimensions: (1) dressing and grooming, (2) arising, (3) eating, (4) walking, (5) hygiene, (6) reach, (7) grip, and (8) common daily activities. The response alternatives were 0 = able without any difficulty, 1 = able with some difficulty, 2 = able with much difficulty, and 3 = unable. The highest response within each subdimension was used as a score for that function and the total HAQ score ranged from 0 to 3.

Maximum walking speed was measured by light cells over a distance of 10 m. Chair rise time (s) was measured using a 43 cm high chair with five repetitions.22 The maximum unilateral isometric strength of the knee extensors was measured using a David 200 dynamometer (Outokumpu, Finland).23 Maximum isometric forces of the trunk flexors and extensors were measured by an isometric strain gauge dynamometer.24 A Jamar standard dynamometer was used to measure isometric grip strength.25 The means for knee extension and grip strength on the right and left side were taken for the subsequent analysis.

Erosions in radiographs of hands and feet were analysed by TS without knowledge of the identity of the patients at the time of reading. Overall pain was assessed on a 100 mm visual analogue scale (VAS).26 The modified 28 joint disease activity score (DAS28)—including 28 tender and swollen joint counts, patient’s self report global status on VAS, and the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR)—was used to evaluate clinical disease activity.27

The ethics committee of Jyväskylä Central Hospital approved the study, and the patients participating gave a written informed consent.

Statistical methods

Variables with a normal distribution were expressed as mean (SD); statistical comparisons between the measures or groups were done using the t test and analysis of variance (ANOVA). If the variables did not have a normal distribution or ordinal, then descriptive values were expressed as medians with interquartile ranges (IQR) or ranges; statistical comparisons between groups were done by using the Mann–Whitney test and a multivariate Hotelling-type permutation test. Measures with a discrete distribution were expressed as counts (%) and analysed by χ2 test or Fischer’s exact test.

Associations between disability (HAQ) and the physical function and disease activity indices were analysed using forward stepwise ordered logit models. Correlation coefficients were calculated by the Spearman method. The multiple imputation method (Markov chain Monte Carlo) was used to fill in missing values for individual HAQ questions. The normality of variables was evaluated by the Shapiro–Wilk statistics. Correlation coefficients were calculated by the Spearman method. The most important descriptive values were expressed with a 95% confidence interval (CI). The α level was set at 0.05 for all tests.

RESULTS

Global health was better and pain less in men than in women (table 1). Other demographic, clinical, and radiological characteristics were similar between the sexes.

Table 1

 Demographic variables and clinical and radiographic characteristics of 135 patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Mean total HAQ in men was 0.67 (95% CI, 0.46 to 0.93) and in women 1.08 (0.95 to 1.22). The difference was statistically significant (p = 0.0031). Women were more disabled in eating, hygiene, reach, grip, and the common daily activities subdimensions of the HAQ (table 2).

Table 2

 Subdimensions of the Health Assessment Questionnaire with individual items in male and female patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Grip strength was 48%, knee extension strength 46%, trunk extension strength 54%, and trunk flexion strength 43% less in female than male rheumatoid patients (table 3). Mean (SD) walking time for 10 m was 6.8 (3.4) s for men and 7.7 (3.2) s for women (p = 0.13). The corresponding times in the sit-to-stand test were 14.3 (5.7) and 16.5 (10.8) (p = 0.28).

Table 3

 Muscle strength in male and female patients with rheumatoid arthritis

In the whole sample, knee extension strength was inversely correlated with walking time (r = −0.63 (95% CI, −0.73 to −0.51)) and the sit-to-stand test (r = −0.47 (−0.60 to −0.31)). Further, the total HAQ disability index was strongly associated with walking time and grip strength (fig 1).

Figure 1

 Association between total Health Assessment Questionnaire score and walking time (A) and grip strength (B). Values are means with 95% confidence intervals.

A higher disease activity (DAS28) and pain score, and lower knee extension and grip strengths entered into the forward ordered logit regression model as an explanatory variable for worse function (higher total HAQ scores) in women, while in men only knee extension strength entered into the model (table 4).

Table 4

 Ordered logit regression models for odds ratios to Health Assessment Questionnaire in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

DISCUSSION

Independent living requires locomotive ability and physical resources. The most reliable evaluation of an individual’s functional capacity can be achieved by combining various self assessments of function with direct measurements.28 The association between muscle strength measurements and functional tests has been described in earlier reports.20,22,29,30

In our previous survey the mean HAQ disability index in the general population aged over 30 years was 0.27 (95% CI, 0.24 to 0.30), and 31% of the respondents reported at least some disability in one of the eight subdimensions of daily living (HAQ ⩾1).31 A high percentage of rheumatoid patients between the ages of 30 and 70 years perceived worse function than reported by the general population.32 In 1982 Fries et al reported a mean total HAQ of 0.80 in 331 rheumatoid patients from a community based population, with an average age of 51 years and a mean duration of disease of 12 years.33 We have reported a similar disability (mean HAQ = 0.92) in rheumatoid patients treated in the rheumatology inpatient ward of our district.34 Among the present subjects, mean HAQ was 0.97 (95% Cl, 0.85 to 1.09) and at least some disability was experienced by 87% of the patients. Thus functional disability among these rheumatoid patients waiting for orthopaedic surgery was both more prevalent and more troublesome than in the general population, while comparable with other studies on rheumatoid patients.

As in our earlier report,32 more women than men in the present cohort reported functional problems. It has been suggested that women may overestimate and men underestimate problems of functional capacity and pain.35,36 On the other hand, the influence of sex on the amount of muscle mass as well as on maximum strength—and thus on the maximum physiological reserve—varies considerably.9,37 In healthy women maximum strength has been reported to be about 52–80% of that in men.9,38,39 In the present study the strength of different muscle groups was 52–57% lower in women than in men with rheumatoid arthritis. Thus the weaker muscles in women with rheumatoid arthritis may make them more vulnerable to functional deficit.

Previous studies have shown significant and progressive loss of grip strength in rheumatoid patients over time.40,41 Significant correlations between grip strength and the self reported global HAQ function have also been found.42,43 In our earlier study we showed that grip strength can explain perceived performance in the subdimensions of “eating,” “reach,” “grip,” and “common daily activities” of the HAQ.34 In the present patients, with their considerably longer disease duration but lower disease activity, grip strength was associated with the same subdimensions of the HAQ that require the ability to grip. Particularly in women, the detected grip strength level (about half of that in males) might be very close to or even below to that required, for example, to open a milk cartoon or cut meat, while men, despite having impaired grip strength values, still have strength well above the required level.

In the present study we also found that decreased knee extension strength was associated with walking speed and sit-to-stand tests in both women and men with rheumatoid arthritis. The sit-to-stand test or the HAQ item “stand up from a straight chair” shows whether the strength level of the knee extensors is adequate or inadequate for chair rise, but it does not provide any information about the amount of an individual’s muscle strength reserve.44,45 Hughes et al reported that older people used 97% of their maximum knee extension strength to get up from a 33 cm high chair.46 In contrast, their younger subjects used only 39% of their maximum strength. Ferrucci L et al have reported that knee extension strength below 10 kg limits the ability to rise from a chair.47 Further, they reported that better strength was associated with better balance.

Pain, stiffness, fatigue, biomechanical deficiencies, and gait deviations may reduce the locomotive capacity of rheumatoid patients. Independent and safe locomotion in the community reportedly requires as a prerequisite a walking speed of 1.4 m/s,47 while carrying out activities of daily living at home requires a walking speed of at least 0.4–0.5 m/s.40,44 In our present study 45% of the patients had a walking speed less than 1.4 m/s, showing that their ability to walk safely may also be at risk. Consequently, if patients’ walking ability is impaired, they cannot be physically active enough to produce the heart and ventilation rates needed to maintain or improve cardiovascular capacity. When all daily activities are carried out slowly and with low effort, the reserve in performance capacity fades. Then, even a small additional strain may lead to a situation where the patient’s independent living becomes endangered or even impossible. Decreased physical activity in turn may gradually lead to obesity, accelerated atherosclerosis, and ultimately to increased comorbidity and mortality in rheumatoid patients.45,46 On the other hand, those with a greater strength reserve may lose even more strength without the threat of crossing the threshold of disability. In the HAQ questionnaire the manner in which the tasks are to be performed is not defined (for example, walking speed, standing up with or without using arms to push off), and thus in everyday life patients may compensate the strength or mobility deficits by using various strategies without becoming conscious of their falling reserve capacity.

The pain level in our present rheumatoid patients waiting for surgery was comparable to that in our earlier report.18 Increases in all eight subdimensions of the HAQ could be explained by pain, suggesting that in part the HAQ measures similar disability constructs to those assessed by the pain scale.32 In the present study perceived pain was also a significant explanatory factor for greater disability in women. Musculoskeletal pain inhibits the motor system and thus prevents or decreases the intensity of muscle contraction during the peak pain, even after the disappearance of the pain sensation.47 Arthritic, injured, and inflamed joints may also cause reflex inhibition without perceived pain.47 A major issue, however, is that rheumatoid patients may avoid strain on account of pain, which in the long run leads to decreased muscle strength and functional capacity.

Generalisation of these results can only be tentative, as the patients participating in our study represent individuals with relatively longstanding rheumatoid arthritis. Further, the number of men was rather small, although their relative proportion (29%) equalled the prevalence of rheumatoid arthritis in men in the population.

In summary, the results indicate that female patients with rheumatoid arthritis report greater disability than male patients, both in the total HAQ disability index and in the majority of its subdimensions. In addition to pain and clinical disease activity, muscle strength has a major impact on physical function.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Published Online First 18 May 2005

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.