Article Text

PDF

Effect of intensive exercise on patients with active RA
  1. S EDMONDS,
  2. C TURNBULL
  1. Department of Rheumatology
  2. Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre
  3. Headington
  4. Oxford, OX3 7LD, UK
  5. Royal National Hospital for Rheumatic Diseases, Upper Borough Walls
  6. Bath BA1 1RL, UK
    1. D BLAKE
    1. Department of Rheumatology
    2. Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre
    3. Headington
    4. Oxford, OX3 7LD, UK
    5. Royal National Hospital for Rheumatic Diseases, Upper Borough Walls
    6. Bath BA1 1RL, UK
      1. C H M VAN DEN ENDE
      1. Netherlands Institute of Health Care Research
      2. The Netherlands
      3. Department of Rheumatology
      4. University Hospital Rotterdam
      5. The Netherlands
        1. J M W HAZES
        1. Netherlands Institute of Health Care Research
        2. The Netherlands
        3. Department of Rheumatology
        4. University Hospital Rotterdam
        5. The Netherlands

          Statistics from Altmetric.com

          The effect of intensive exercise on disease activity in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is an interesting one.1 Although we would not dispute that such exercise does indeed have a beneficial effect on parameters of disease activity, we wish to propose an alternative hypothesis as to its mechanism. In particular, we would argue that the effect of raised intra-articular pressure on synovial blood flow during exercise is not as the authors suggest.

          The intra-articular pressure in chronically inflamed joints undoubtedly rises during exercise, and exceeds capillary perfusion pressure within the synovium.2 3 This pressure rise occurs in joints with and without effusions. It is clearly difficult to measure intra-articular pressure during dynamic exercise, but we would speculate that the pressure rises which occur during dynamic exercise are similar to those occurring during static exercise. The study that is quoted by the authors suggests that synovial blood flow increases during dynamic exercise such as walking and cycling and was only measured in joints with effusions.4 We would argue that raised intra-articular pressure during any form of exercise not onlycompromises synovial blood flow, resulting in synovial hypoxia, but is the initiating step in reperfusion injury.5 Hypoxia-reperfusion injury is one of the mechanisms by which reactive oxygen species (ROS) are produced, including the highly toxic hydroxyl radical.6 Damage by such ROS to biomolecules and tissues within the rheumatoid joint is well documented.7 8 Oxidative damage to fine nociceptor nerve endings within the synovium renders the joint relatively anaesthetic9 and perhaps allows the patient to exercise the joint more vigorously. We propose therefore that intensive exercise brings about an “auto-synovectomy”, effectively reducing the amount of inflammation within the joint and thereby reducing the disease activity score.

          References

          Authors' reply

          In our study we observed a statistically non-significant decrease in all measured parameters of disease activity in patients with active rheumatoid arthritis who participated in an intensive exercise programme. In all exercise forms only the larger joints, in particular, the knee joints, were involved. None of the exercises focused on the hand joints. We assessed the 28 swollen joint count as proposed by Fuchs and Pincus.1-1 If intensive exercise brings about an “auto-synovectomy” as suggested by Edmonds and colleagues one would expect a decrease in the number of swollen knees and a stable number of swollen joints in the hand. To test this hypothesis we compared in our data the number of swollen knee and hand joints (proximal interphalangeal joints and metacarpophalangeal joints) at baseline and at 24 weeks of follow up in patients who completed the study.

          Table 1-1 shows that within the group undergoing intensive exercise both the number of swollen knees and the number of swollen hand joints decreased significantly. Differences between groups were not statistically significant. In our opinion hypoxia-reperfusion injury may induce “auto-synovectomy”, but this hypothesis does not fully explain the decrease in inflammation after vigorous exercise in other than exercised joints.

          Table 1-1

          Changes in numbers of swollen knee and hand joints in patients randomly assigned to an intensive or conservative exercise programme during a stay in hospital

          References

          1. 1-1.
          View Abstract

          Request permissions

          If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

          Linked Articles