Article Text


Impaired microvascular response to cholinergic stimuli in primary Sjögren's syndrome


OBJECTIVE Signs of a parasympathetic dysfunction have been revealed in primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS). Its role in the pathogenesis and the clinical picture of the disease is not clear. To investigate the responsiveness of SS patients to a cholinergic agonist, a model was used involving examination of the cutaneous microcirculation. The microvascular response to the administration of carbachol was measured, a muscarinic cholinergic agonist.

METHODS Twenty two SS patients and 12 controls were examined. Carbachol and 0.9% saline solution were administered intracutaneously into the forearm skin at two distinct places. Skin blood flow (SBF) in the injected areas was measured continuously before and for 10 minutes after the injections by means of a laser Doppler perfusion monitor. The increase in SBF in response to carbachol (dSBF), reflecting vasodilatation, was calculated by a formula including the baseline and the maximum SBF values after the injections of carbachol and saline solution.

RESULTS The vasodilatation was significantly lower in SS patients than in the controls (mean dSBF: 2.1 (range: 1.0–4.5) versus 3.3 (range: 1.7–7.6), p=0.02). With non-responder patients defined as those in whom a smaller response was observed than in any of the controls, 11 of the 22 SS patients proved to be non-responders to carbachol. Comparisons of demographic, clinical and laboratory characteristics and HLA class II genotypes between responder and non-responder SS patients did not show any significant differences.

CONCLUSIONS A diminished or absent response to carbachol indicates a cholinergic dysfunction in SS patients. A disturbance in the neurotransmission at a receptorial or postreceptorial level is hypothesised. Unresponsiveness to cholinergic stimuli may contribute to exocrine insufficiency.

  • primary Sjögren's syndrome
  • cholinergic
  • vasodilatation

Statistics from

Dry mouth and dry eyes, the two fundamental symptoms of primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS), have previously been regarded solely as direct consequences of the loss of functioning glandular tissue caused by an autoimmune inflammatory process. However, this conception is now increasingly questioned.1 2 The symptoms of dryness and the quantitatively determined saliva and tear production may vary greatly during the course of the disease, even without treatment, and their spontaneous improvement is often observed for varying periods. A marked discrepancy has been reported between the degree of exocrine insufficiency and the histologically verified intensity of the inflammatory infiltration in the salivary glands.3 In human and animal experiments, several types of abnormalities of the autonomic nervous system have been demonstrated in SS.4-10

The question of whether an impairment of parasympathetic innervation may play a part in the elicitation of exocrine insufficiency in SS remains an issue to be examined. Despite previous work, results of human functional studies on the parasympathetic nervous system in SS patients are by no means numerous. If a postulated cholinergic dysfunction does exist, it is not known whether it is caused by a central or a peripheral nervous system dysfunction, or whether it reflects a disorder of the parasympathetic innervation at a receptorial or postreceptorial level. Nor is it clear whether the acetylcholine transmitter system or a non-adrenergic, non-cholinergic transmitter (for example, vasoactive intestinal polypeptide (VIP)) system colocalised in the cholinergic nerve terminals is involved.11

For these reasons, we set out to examine the response to the administration of a muscarinic cholinergic agonist, carbachol, in SS patients and to compare it with that in healthy controls. To measure this response, we established a model involving examination of the cutaneous microcirculation. A cholinergic vasodilatory mechanism of the human skin blood vessels has long been verified.12-14 As this is similar in many respects to the cholinergic innervation of the salivary glands,13 we decided to use this experimental setting to test the hypothesis that a cholinergic dysfunction exists in SS patients.



Twenty two primary SS patients (20 female and 2 male) were enrolled in the study. All were diagnosed as having SS by the European Community criteria15 at the Division of Autoimmune Diseases at the 1st Department of Internal Medicine, Albert Szent-Györgyi Medical University, Szeged, Hungary. The average age of the patients was (mean (SD)) 50.6 (13.2) years (33–60). The average time since the first symptom had appeared was (mean (SD))11.5 (5.2) years (4–24), while the average time since the establishment of the diagnosis was (mean (SD)) 9.1 (6.7) years (3–20). In 18 of the 22 patients, a minor salivary gland biopsy had been performed. In 17 of these 18 patients, histological examination revealed focal lymphocytic sialadenitis, meeting the histological criteria of SS, while in one patient a negative result was obtained. In this latter patient and in the four patients on whom no biopsy was performed, the appropriate number of other criteria for the diagnosis of SS was met. All patients were regularly followed up. To exclude other factors that might possibly influence the microcirculatory physiology, SS patients older than 60 years, those who had hypertension or clinical evidence of arteriosclerosis (coronary heart disease, arteriosclerotic cerebral disease or arteriosclerosis in other organs) or peripheral neuropathy, and those who regularly took β-adrenergic blockers, calcium channel blockers, pentoxyphylline, or other drugs with vasodilatory or anticholinergic properties, were regarded as not eligible for the study. For the same reason, the use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs was suspended at least five days before the examinations. The patients were asked to refrain from smoking or the drinking of coffee on the day of the examination.

Twelve healthy, age and sex matched people were examined as controls. None of these subjects had any known illness, or were taking any regular medication. All gave their informed consent to the procedure and the study design was accepted by the Medical Ethics Board of Albert Szent-Györgyi Medical University.


During examinations, the patients and controls were in the supine position. The skin blood flow (SBF) was measured with a laser-Doppler flowmeter (Penflux, Perimed) attached to the skin on the flexor surface of the right forearm, and blood flow values were expressed in arbitrary units.16 Three ECG electrodes were attached to the chest and the heart rate was monitored continuously, as was the blood pressure by means of a photoplethysmographic blood pressure monitor (Finapres 2300, Ohmeda) attached to a finger of the right hand (beat to beat registration). The subjects were asked to lie at rest with their eyes closed. The room temperature was kept constant (20°C ± 1°C) and all disturbing factors were excluded. The baseline SBF was recorded for five minutes; the blood flow was stable by the end of this period and the SBF value measured at five minutes was defined as SBF basal. Then 0.1 ml of carbachol (Miostat, Alcon, USA), a muscarinic receptor agonist, was injected intracutaneously into the forearm skin. As control, almost simultaneously, 0.1 ml of 0.9% saline solution was injected similarly into the forearm skin at approximately 10 cm from the other injection site. SBF was measured simultaneously at the two injection sites for another 10 minutes and the highest deviations from the baseline flow values were designated SBF final.

All recorded data (heart rate, systolic and diastolic arterial pressure and SBF) were stored in a computer database and were analysed by means of a self developed software. The change in SBF in response to the injection of carbachol (dSBF) was calculated using the following formula:

Embedded Image

Thus, dSBF is the ratio of the SBF values measured after and before the injection of carbachol divided by the same ratio for the control solution of physiological saline. This calculation allowed us to eliminate the absolute flow values and also to eliminate possible non-specific microcirculatory effects of the intracutaneous injection. In every subject, the mean values of the RR intervals on the ECG, and the systolic, diastolic and mean arterial pressures were also recorded. The cutaneous vascular resistance (CVR) was calculated by dividing the mean arterial pressure by SBF, while dCVR was calculated with a formula analogous to that for dSBF.


Laboratory examinations were performed as follows: anti-SSA and anti-SSB antibodies: enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (Epignost, Leonding/Linz, Austria); antinuclear antibodies: indirect immunofluorescence assay, using rat liver as substrate; IgM rheumatoid factor: quantitative measurements by immunoturbidimetry (Boehringer Mannheim, Germany). HLA DRB1, DQA1 and DQB1 genotyping was performed by using methods described in detail by others.17-20Schirmer's test and sialometry were performed within one year from the examinations in all SS patients. As sialometric examination, we assessed the unstimulated whole saliva production in 10 minutes. Skin dryness was scored on a scale 0–IV on the basis of the patients' reports of the severity of dry skin complaints and physical examination of the skin, as follows: grade 0: no dry skin; grade I: a transient feeling of skin dryness not requiring treatment, and no objective signs of dry skin; grade II: a recurrent feeling of skin dryness requiring treatment with hydrating lotions, and objective signs of decreased sweat production; grade III: a continuous feeling of skin dryness revealed by topical treatment, and severely dry skin with fine scaling; grade IV: a continuous feeling of skin dryness not revealed by topical treatment, and very severely dry skin with excoriations and mild loss of hair.


Differences between means were calculated with an independent sample t test, except for the comparison of the means of dSBF values, where Wilcoxon'st test was applied because of the non-parametric distribution of the elements of the samples. For the comparisons of frequencies, Fisher's exact test was used, with Bonferroni's correction when the examined variable had more than two possible values (for example, HLA genotype). To investigate correlations with dSBF, Spearman's signed rank test or linear regression analysis was applied. Statistical calculations were performed with SPSS software. Values in the text are expressed as mean (SD). The level of significance was defined as p<0.05.


Table 1 gives details relating to the occurrences of the main systemic organ manifestations of SS and the various laboratory parameters in the 22 patients.

Table 1

Occurrences of main organ manifestations and laboratory variables in primary Sjögren's syndrome patients (n=22)

Table 2 reports the average values of the most important haemodynamic variables in the two groups recorded during the examinations of the cutaneous microcirculation. We present here the means of the changes in the local blood flow in response to carbachol (SBFfinal,carbachol/SBFbasal,carbachol) and physiological saline solution (SBFfinal,saline/SBFbasal,saline), the dSBF values (which are specific indicators of the cutaneous vasodilatation in response to the cholinergic agonist), and also the corresponding values of the change in CVR. The means of the continuously recorded values of the RR intervals on the ECG and of systemic arterial blood pressure are also included in table 2.

Table 2

Comparison of certain haemodynamic variables in primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS) patients and controls recorded during the blood flow examinations

In the event of a positive vascular reaction, the blood flow started to increase within 30 seconds after the injection of carbachol and reached a new steady state approximately 4–7 minutes later, then remaining unchanged until the end of the examination. In the controls, the average dSBF was 3.30 (1.79), which was significantly higher than the average dSBF in SS patients (2.07 (1.12)) (p=0.019) (fig 1). In the controls, the dSBF values reflected a 1.66–7.6-fold increase in microcirculatory blood flow after the injection of carbachol. However, in a relatively high proportion of the SS patients, the reaction to the administration of carbachol was small or virtually absent, while in other patients a marked vasodilatation was observed. We defined a positive microvascular reaction to carbachol in the SS patients as a dSBF value higher than the smallest dSBF value in the group of healthy controls. Following this definition, exactly half of the SS patients (11 of 22) could be considered to be non-responders—that is, producing a less than 1.66-fold increase in the microcirculatory blood flow—while the other half of the patients were regarded as responders to carbachol on the basis of the pronounced vasodilatation (a more than 1.66-fold increase in SBF).

Figure 1

Distribution of dSBF values in primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS) patients and healthy controls. dSBF: change in skin blood flow in response to the injection of carbachol. Continuous lines indicate means. Values above the dashed lines indicate a positive response to carbachol.

We examined whether there was any difference in certain demographic characteristics or in the frequencies of certain clinical organ involvements between the SS patients defined as non-responders or as responders to carbachol (table 3). The age of the patients and the time since the appearance of the first symptom of SS was similar in the two groups. Similarly, when tested by linear regression analysis, the above variables did not demonstrate any correlation with dSBF (data not shown). No statistically significant difference was revealed between the two groups in the occurrence of any of the main organ manifestations. However, it is noteworthy that all the examined organ involvements occurred more frequently in the responder patients (with the exception of pulmonary fibrosis, which occurred in one patient in each of the subgroups) (table 3). Dry skin is a common complaint in SS patients. In table 4, we present the proportions of patients with varying degrees of severity of skin dryness. We checked whether there was a correlation between the reactivity of the cutaneous microcirculatory vessels to carbachol (dSBF) and the degree of skin dryness, which is predominantly a consequence of the insufficiency of the exocrine glands of the skin; the answer proved negative. The two subgroups were also comparable as concerns the average values of tear and saliva production (mean tear flow with Schirmer's test: 4.0 (2.12)v 4.45 (2.21) mm/5 minutes, unstimulated whole saliva flow: 0.34 (0.28) v 0.32 (0.28) ml/10 minutes in the non-responders and in the responders, respectively).

Table 3

Demographic characteristics and occurrences of certain organ manifestations of primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS) in carbachol responder and non-responder SS patients

Table 4

Numbers of people with various degrees of severity of skin dryness among the primary Sjögren's syndrome patients (n=22)

The frequencies of anti-SSA, anti-SSB, IgM RF and ANA positivity, and also the average levels of laboratory markers of a chronic autoimmune inflammatory process, in particular the erythrocyte sedimentation rate, fibrinogen concentration, anaemia and γ globulin concentration, did not differ significantly in the two subgroups of primary SS patients. No HLA DR, DQA1 and DQB1 allele occurred more frequently in one subgroup than in the other, although, in view of the relatively small number of patients and the heterogeneity of the genotypes of the examined persons, a statistically significant difference is hardly to be expected (data not shown).

The drug treatment applied throughout the course of the illness was also surveyed. The proportions of patients treated with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, hydroxychloroquine or corticosteroids were similar in the two subgroups. Two patients were receiving regular corticosteroid treatment and five hydroxychloroquine treatment at the time of the examination; the use of these drugs did not seem to influence the microcirculatory response to carbachol, as indicated by the similar proportions of users in the responder and non-responder subgroups.


The purpose of this study was to determine the proportion of primary SS patients who demonstrate signs of a cholinergic dysfunction, and to evaluate whether there is a relation between the presence of a cholinergic dysfunction and certain clinical, serological and genetic characteristics of the disease. The importance of this question stems from the fact that the salivary glands are richly innervated by cholinergic nerve fibres, and, if the hypothesis that there is a disturbance in the cholinergic innervation proves true, this may provide new aspects as regards the pathogenesis of the sicca symptoms in SS. The issue of abnormalities in the parasympathetic nervous system in SS has arisen in previous human or animal studies in which various stages of the parasympathetic innervation pathway were investigated. Mandl et al 6 and Andonopouloset al 7 detected autonomic neuropathy, mainly affecting the parasympathetic nerves. Santavirtaet al 8 demonstrated that the salivary outputs of VIP (considered a marker of the parasympathetic innervation) and of neuropeptide Y (a marker of sympathetic innervation) were both increased as compared with healthy controls. They suggested that this phenomenon is associated with an altered response to stress in SS patients. In immunohistological examinations, Konttinen et al 4 found that VIP containing parasympathetic fibres were absent from regions of the parotid glands where inflammatory cell infiltration and acinar atrophy were severe. Circulating antibodies against rat parotid M3 muscarinic cholinergic receptors were detected by Bacman et al.9 Törnvall et al 5 reported that the expression of the βII and α isoforms of protein kinase C, a crucial member of the intracellular second messenger pathway of cholinergic neurotransmission, was deficient on the salivary gland acinar epithelial cells in SS patients as compared with controls. In contrast with healthy controls, the ξ and βII isoforms were undetected on the myoepithelial cells in SS patients. These findings are suggestive of a postreceptorial disturbance of the cholinergic innervation.

In this study, we examined the cutaneous cholinergic vasodilatation in SS patients in response to the local administration of a muscarinic cholinergic agonist, carbachol. Acetylcholine has been demonstrated to cause vasodilatation in healthy humans.13 Although the non-adrenergic–non-cholinergic transmitter systems probably play a more important part in the physiological vasoregulation in the skin than do the cholinergic nerves, receptors for acetylcholine can also be found in the cutaneous microvasculature.21 Carbachol has been demonstrated to induce phospholipase C dependent saliva secretion through stimulation of the muscarinic cholinergic receptors in human salivary acinar cells.22 23 The same muscarinic receptors have been implicated in the cholinergic vasodilatation in human cutaneous arterioles in response to body heat stress.13These findings provide a basis for our choice of an investigation of the cutaneous microcirculation as a model of the parasympathetic innervation of the salivary glands. Nevertheless, firm conclusions can be drawn only after examinations directly involving the salivary glands in SS patients.

We found that the average increase in cutaneous microcirculatory blood flow in response to carbachol was significantly smaller in the SS patients than in the healthy controls. In half of the SS patients, the reaction to a potent parasympathomimetic drug was virtually absent or markedly diminished. As vasodilatation is characterised physiologically by a decrease in vascular resistance, the CVR was also calculated by dividing the mean arterial pressure by SBF. As the arterial pressure remained virtually unchanged in all the examined persons during the examinations, an increase in SBF always reflected cutaneous vasodilatation in this experimental setting.

The above finding lends support to previous results suggesting a disturbance in the parasympathetic autonomic nervous system in SS. As our experiments involved the administration of a muscarinic receptor agonist directly to the examined target organ, the detected unresponsiveness favours the hypothesis that a dysfunction may exist at a receptorial or post-receptorial level. To test whether a receptorial dysfunction may result from a structural abnormality of the receptor protein caused by an abnormal genetic coding, we determined the HLA DRB1, DQA1 and DQB1 genotype profiles in our study patients. Certain HLA alleles (most importantly HLA-DR3) are known to occur more frequently in SS patients than in the general population. However, the hypothesis that an acetylcholine receptor pathology may be determined by a genetic predisposition remains an open question, as our relatively small patient population does not allow firm conclusions in this regard. Anti-receptor antibodies, similarly to myasthenia gravis, may be other possible causes of a receptor dysfunction. Indeed, antibodies against rat M3 muscarinic receptors have been detected in SS patients,9 though the existence and possible role of anti-receptorial antibodies against human muscarinic receptors have not been verified.

It has been hypothesised that an interaction may occur in the salivary glands between the infiltrating inflammatory cells and certain neuropeptides.4 In contrast, another hypothesis suggests that the loss of trophic stimuli from the parasympathetic nerves in the salivary glands might be a cause of acinar cell atrophy, and this may contribute to the decreased saliva production.4 Our results relating to investigation of a target organ distant from the areas of lymphocytic inflammation suggest that a disorder of the cholinergic receptors may not be restricted to the exocrine glands, but may be a more widely occurring phenomenon, and that this defect is possibly independent of the local inflammatory process. Further investigations may yield results of general importance as concerns the interactions between the nervous system and the immune system.

As a considerable proportion of the SS patients displayed a fundamentally insignificant reaction to carbachol, we could divide our population of SS patients into responders and non-responders to the cholinergic agent. The occurrence of unresponsiveness did not correlate with the age of the patients, the disease duration, the presence of a specific organ manifestation (including vascular manifestations of the disease) or of an autoantibody, nor the severity of the functional impairment of the salivary and lachrymal glands. However, all the organ involvements proved to be more common in the responder patients than in the non-responders. Confirmation of this latter finding with statistically significant results is first necessary before an explanation can be suggested.

In summary, we found that half of the examined SS patients proved to be non-responders to the administration of the cholinergic receptor agonist carbachol. Whether this unresponsiveness also relates to the clinically involved exocrine glands, and the precise mechanism of the disorder in the cholinergic innervation, possibly at a receptorial or postreceptorial level, are features that remain to be clarified.


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.